Glee - Mash-Up [1x08] - Episode Discussion. - Page 8

**Queen Bee** · 10-23-2009, 06:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coutureadore (View Post)

Agreed! I really wish they would've added jealous Finn & Quinn

I would've lovvvvvvvvved that. I mean we got a taste of jealous!Finn, but I would've liked more.

free2live · 10-23-2009, 09:54 AM

Yeah, we got one shot of jealous!Finn and googly-eyed!Quinn but nothing much...

portiaslegacy · 10-25-2009, 12:47 PM

This might not be an appropriate thing to post here, but I am not sure where to do it.

I really don't like the character of Puck. I resent his airtime and dont believe in him, let alone ship him with Rachel or Quinn. Also some of the fan reaction to his character I dont see how this episode would make some one like him more than Finn.

Also Puck's decision to date Rachel was entirely about fetishizing her Jewishness. He did not like listening to her sing, did not think highly of her decision to make out with him. I liked the break up scene, but that was it.

It was a disapointing episode. Other than Mathew Morison dancin there was not much to like about it

coutureadore · 10-25-2009, 10:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by portiaslegacy (View Post)

This might not be an appropriate thing to post here, but I am not sure where to do it.

I really don't like the character of Puck. I resent his airtime and dont believe in him, let alone ship him with Rachel or Quinn. Also some of the fan reaction to his character I dont see how this episode would make some one like him more than Finn.

Also Puck's decision to date Rachel was entirely about fetishizing her Jewishness. He did not like listening to her sing, did not think highly of her decision to make out with him. I liked the break up scene, but that was it.

It was a disapointing episode. Other than Mathew Morison dancin there was not much to like about it

I'm sorry you feel that way. I for one like Puck. At first I didn't but he slowly grew on me...maybe he'll grow on you too. I think his character has potential.

I thought this episode was okay...nothing really was exciting for me except seeing Emma sing

I love her voice.

Next Wednesday's episode should be good.

Kyls · 10-26-2009, 02:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by portiaslegacy (View Post)

I liked the break up scene, but that was it.

Same here. Except where he referred to Rachel as "a girl like you." Shows that he still doesn't think much of her.

And I don't think much of Puck either.

onetreehill4lyfireland · 10-26-2009, 03:53 AM

love it!! amazing! wat a good idea bu i hope d dont just burst into song in the weirdist of times much lol............loved bust it

chemistry86 · 10-26-2009, 09:50 AM

I think when Puck said 'a girl like you' he was just wounded in his pride so I don't think he meant it.

portiaslegacy · 10-26-2009, 06:55 PM

Re: "a girl like you" comment. He meant it. It was not all hurt pride, he never really was thinking of her as a person. Just "nice Jewish girl". Rachel may identify ethnically with Barbara Streisand and Natalie Wood, but she would not want to be reduced to just that.

Ellie Cameron · 11-13-2009, 01:51 PM

this was an okay episode. I watched it yesterday, I was still catching up.

I don't like Puck/Rachel. during the sweet caroline performance though it looked like the song evoked emotion in Quinn and made her feel special. but I hate that it was for Rachel