The Fringe Guest Stars Thread #3 - Because they are just as important to Fringe as the Bishops and Olivia
 

Reposting the game -

Voting for Most Evil so far:

David Robert Jones = 1
Windmark = 1

Next round - Who is the Most Evil Villain of Fringe?

The candidates are listed below.

The Best Villains of Fringe
1. Creepiest - Anson Carr
2. Most Ruthless - Windmark



Hey! I'm going to kick off a new game in this thread. It's a voting game, but not as restrictive as a typical survivor. The point is not to eliminate or vote off anything. Instead, it's more of a "Best in Class" vote. I've played versions of this in another board and it's been a lot of fun, so I hope everyone here will enjoy it.

As the title above suggests, this is to vote on The Best Villains of Fringe.

Here's how it works:
Below is a list of 12 character attributes, and pictures of 12 Fringe Villains, with brief summaries of their roles.
Starting with the first attribute on the list, we vote for which villain best fits that attribute.
The villain who first reaches five votes "wins" that attribute and we go to the next on the list.
We'll use the 48 hour rule if no one gets to 5 votes.

This is NOT an elimination or survivor game.
You CAN vote for the same villain for two or more different attributes. The same villain may win in two or more categories.
If you think one villain is Wierdest, but also Creepiest, you are free to vote for that person in both categories.

So, to start off, which of the characters pictured below do you think is the Creepiest?

Here are the villains:

The Candidates
1. Anson Carr - 4.15 A Short Story About Love
2. David Robert Jones - recurring
3. Leland Spivey - 4.07 Wallflower
4. Milo Stanfield - 3.03 The Plateau
5. Mitchell Loeb - recurring, season 1
6. Sanford Harris - recurring, season 1
7. Shapeshifter Charlie - recurring, 2.01 - 2.04
8. Thomas Jerome Newton - recurring
9. Tyler Carson - 2.07 Of Human Action
10. Walternate - recurring
11. William Bell - recurring
12. Windmark - recurring late season 4 through season 5

And here are the attributes - feel free to suggest others!
1. Creepiest
2. Most Ruthless
3. Most Evil
4. The villian you can't help liking
5. Most Misunderstood
6. Most Devious
7. Most Corrupt
8. The villian you love to hate
9. Most Criminal
10. Most Immoral
11. Most Disturbing
12. Wierdest

Tftnt! :p

I've been pondering this for a while and I have to go with DRJ as Most Evil.

Windmark is too emotionless for me to consider him evil. I know there's not necessarily a connection there, but for me, there is. Or perhaps I should say that, not being human, I don't expect Windmark to have the same sense of good vs evil - right vs wrong - and so I don't see evil as being at the root of what he does. He's like a robot - he does what he's programmed to do and it is neither good nor evil, it just is.

DRJ is human - with human emotions. From his reactions and expressions it seems he knows full well that what he's doing is evil - and he's enjoying it.

David Robert Jones = 2
Windmark = 1

I kind of agree, but yet I don't because Windmark is the other side of the coin from September. September and August were different because they felt "love", whereas Windmark admitted he felt "Hate".

As far as David Robert Jones, he was evil, but he was also just a puppet and a means to an "end". Remember he was the "Bishop" (S4)

So I guess that means I vote for Windmark as Most Evil Villian.

Good points.

And we now have a tie.

David Robert Jones = 2
Windmark = 2

We need to break that tie :D

Wow! :birthday:

Cool, happy belated birthday to him :yay:

That guy totally creeps me out. :no:

Me too, since RoboCop. :borg: