David Cook - Cook on American Idol #3: Because we still love to rewatch his performances over and over. - Page 2

Street Spirit · 11-12-2011, 01:39 PM

Hi, jc1941. I'm Jas.

It is a great list. Do you have a favorite David performance from AI?

Cereal Killer · 11-20-2011, 12:32 PM

Hello jc1941

Welcome to

, hope to see you again!

I agree, that's quite an track record for anyone's AI run.

Street Spirit · 11-22-2011, 04:14 AM

How about we rewatch this performance again? Just amazing is all I can say.

Cereal Killer · 11-27-2011, 01:50 PM

I had actually just watched that around the time you posted the video.

You're right, it's still totally amazing. Everything about it is just perfect, the honesty and the emotion of the performance and of course his vocals. His tears get me every time.

And Paula's comment still remains my favorite out of anything any judge has ever said on that show. She nailed it.

Street Spirit · 11-30-2011, 03:04 AM

I bet you fell in love with Paula right then.

Gotta agree with everything you said, not much else to add.

ETA:

I'm watching this performance right now. Love it a lot. Maybe David should cover more U2 songs.

Cereal Killer · 01-04-2012, 03:53 PM

I did not fall in love with her but I did like her more than I ever had or have after that. xD

I'm glad you agree, TWIK was truly special.

Aw, I love ISHFWILF, definitely my favorite along with ABMB and TWIK.

David covering more U2 would be awesome!

Sooo... I'm wondering what we should do about the rewatch that's been going on in this thread for approximately 153.65 years. I think we got all the way up to ABMB or MOTN. And we wrote all those lovely comments too.

Mainly going out of order is what bothers me, I apologize me for my OCD, I really do.

colourtunes · 01-04-2012, 07:04 PM

No matter how many times I watch it, TWIK gets me every. single. time.

And I suppose we could always start over in order, Laura. I for one wouldn't mind watching any of the performances yet again.

Cereal Killer · 01-05-2012, 01:54 AM

Quote:

No matter how many times I watch it, TWIK gets me every. single. time.

Me too. It's ingenious and perfect in every way.

Quote:

And I suppose we could always start over in order, Laura. I for one wouldn't mind watching any of the performances yet again.

Well, if we do that, I'm just gonna repost all my old comments.

If we do start over, can we wait until I get back before we start though?

Street Spirit · 01-05-2012, 06:19 AM

Of course, Laura! When you come back we can all start.

And we'll figure how to order/start it and all that too. Still not sure what you guys want to do.

Quote:

Originally Posted by colourtunes (View Post)

No matter how many times I watch it, TWIK gets me every. single. time.

I adore it so much too! Wonderful song, moving performance, and David's tears at the end.

Cereal Killer · 01-05-2012, 06:30 AM

Thanks.

I would like to go in the order the show went. Starting with the audition to Hollywood to semi-finals and then the finals down to the finale. Like watching the show again but just David's parts.

And of course the results shows and Ford videos of each week.

Sound good?

Quote:

David's tears at the end.

THIS. My weakness every time.

Tugi · 01-05-2012, 08:38 PM

The Ford videos

So priceless!
Don't think I'll ever forget that one where he plays the director. You know he just loved it!

Street Spirit · 01-06-2012, 02:15 AM

Sounds good, Laura. Hopefully everything can be found on youtube.

How can it not be your weakness, those tears?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tugi (View Post)

The Ford videos

So priceless!
Don't think I'll ever forget that one where he plays the director. You know he just loved it!

I'm looking forward to rewatching the Ford videos as I don't remember a lot of them!

Cereal Killer · 01-15-2012, 01:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tugi (View Post)

The Ford videos

So priceless!
Don't think I'll ever forget that one where he plays the director. You know he just loved it!

Beat the group numbers every time.

Haha, I love that one, "it's called acting, Chikezie!"

(Also Michael was pretty stellar at that one.

)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Street Spirit (View Post)

Sounds good, Laura. Hopefully everything can be found on youtube.

Everything could be found at least the last time we did a rewatch.

Quote:

How can it not be your weakness, those tears?

They are what started my Cookification after ABMB.

Quote:

I'm looking forward to rewatching the Ford videos as I don't remember a lot of them!

There were lots of great ones! It'll be really fun watching them again.

I can post the videos if you guys want. Since I know/remember what should come when from the last time.

Just a suggestion though.

Street Spirit · 01-16-2012, 04:53 AM

I fell in love with David after his 'Hello' performance. I think?

At the very least, David caught my eye then.

It will be fun to watch them again. We're doing the same over at the Kris board.

Quote:

I can post the videos if you guys want. Since I know/remember what should come when from the last time. Just a suggestion though.

Go for it, Laura.

Cereal Killer · 05-21-2012, 04:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Street Spirit (View Post)

I fell in love with David after his 'Hello' performance. I think?

At the very least, David caught my eye then.

Yeah, he had you at 'Hello'.

Quote:

It will be fun to watch them again. We're doing the same over at the Kris board.

Sooo... We never did it.

I'm sorry about that.

But we can start the rewatch now if you're still interested.

---

First things first though!

Four years ago today, May 21st, this happened:

Still my favorite moment in the history of TV. :')


Fan Forum > Archived Music Artists > David Cook > Cook on American Idol #3: Because we still love to rewatch his performances over and over.