[strawberrypie]

Okay, let's try a different question...

What if Ned and Emerson had met when they were kids?

[Katiegg108]

Emerson probably would be beat Ned up.

What if there was suddenly no crimes for Ned to solve?

[strawberrypie]

Why would he beat Ned up?

He'd have more time to make pies and be with Chuck

What if Chuck had the gift instead of Ned?

[strawberrypie]

[Starfield_Scribe]

I don't know how to answer that question!

[strawberrypie]

Originally Posted by strawberrypie (View Post) What if Chuck had the gift instead of Ned?

[ice_ice_baby]

Then her father wouldn't have died or he would have been brought back sooner.


What if Vivian was Chuck's mother instead of Lily?

[strawberrypie]

Chuck would have grown up with her parents and Lily wouldn't have to keep secrets from her sister.

What if... Emerson and Olive fell in love?

[ice_ice_baby]

She'd have to stand on one of the Pie Hole's booth seats to kiss him.


What if Emerson was in love with Chuck?

[strawberrypie]

Originally Posted by ice_ice_baby (View Post) She'd have to stand on one of the Pie Hole's booth seats to kiss him.

Now I'm picturing that

Then he'd have to learn how to make pies to impress her.

What if one of Chuck's ex-boyfriends shows up?

[ice_ice_baby]

Ned would poison his pie


What if one of Ned's ex-girlfriends shows up... dead in the morgue?

[strawberrypie]

Originally Posted by ice_ice_baby (View Post) Ned would poison his pie

I can totally picture him doing that and then feeling guilty about it .

What if one of Ned's ex-girlfriends shows up... dead in the morgue?

Then he'd know he's cursed and would certainly need therapy.

What if Lily and Vivian find out Charles Charles is alive again?