[Katiegg108]

There would have been a major cat fight And I'm thinking Vivian would have pulled a surprise win.

What if Olive stayed at the nunnery?

[lala000]

The gang would be sad.

What if Ned had met Chuck before she died?

[Katiegg108]

She wouldn't have had to be the "lonely tourist" so she never would have died.

What if Emerson worked in the Pie Hole?

[strawberrypie]

The atmosphere of the place would be a lot less sweet and a lot more sarcastic.

What if Olive had never run away to the nunnery?

[lala000]

The secrets she was holding would come out sooner

What if Olive had found out about Ned's secret early on?

[Katiegg108]

They would have gotten a lot closer because he wouldn't have been hiding things from her

What if it was revealed to the world that Chuck is alive?

[strawberrypie]

Ned would probably have to hide for a while

What if Ned's mom hadn't died?

[Katiegg108]

Ned and Chuck never would have been separated.

What if Ned accidentally touched Digby?

[strawberrypie]

I would cry like a baby.

What if Olive was the piemaker and Ned the waiter?

[iingenious]

Ned would be the one breaking out in song every time he pined for Olive

What if Olive ended up staying in the convent?

[Katiegg108]

She'd eventually go mad.

What if Emerson's pop-up books got published?

[daritah]

Children around the world would want to be PI's.

What if Ned's dream in S1 wasn't a dream?

[strawberrypie]

The hotness would surely burn my tv

What if Ned's dad hadn't abandoned him?

[Katiegg108]

Ned wouldn't have so many issues.

What if Olive and Ned were a couple when Chuck came into the picture?

[takeitgreen]

He would've touched Chuck a second time ^^

What if Emerson had been the victim of ~proximity when Ned un-deaded Chuck?