 |
| ||||||||||||||||||
|
|  |
|  | |
|
|  |
|  | | ||||||
 |  | |||||||||
|
| #16 | |||
| Master Fan  Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 12,922
| You're not a Mer/Der fan anymore Lis?  If you want your name off the Ferryboats list on the GA board let me know and I'll take it off. __________________ Visit the 90's Board!  | |||
|
| #17 | |||
| Master Fan  Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,342
| Quote:
Meredith tried to kill herself for real problems, Addison cheated him without a real reason. Opinion. | |||
|
|
| #18 | |||
| Master Fan Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 12,922
| I agree Gio. You can try and overcome a suicide attempt. I mean look at ER. Carol attempted suicide in the Pilot but yet her and Doug ended up together in the end. Now if it had been cheating that would have been a whole different ballgame and I doubt they would have ever been back together. __________________ Visit the 90's Board! | |||
|
|
| #19 | |||
| Total Fan  Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 7,069
| karen, i look forward to your icons. i'm sure you are having lots of fun with the patrick ones. __________________ when a lady walks up 2 me and says, "hey do you know what's sexy" i say "no but i can add up all the change in your purse very fast | |||
|
|
| #20 | |||
| Master Fan  Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 11,666
| Quote:
Gio- Comparing Addison and Meredith seems to be a redundant issue on this thread. __________________ even if things end up a bit too heavy | |||
|
|
| #21 | |||
| Master Fan Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,342
| Lis it was an example because they are the two Derek's women. If you "hate" a suicidal girlfriend, I suppose you also "hate" a cheater wife. Steph I loved Doug and Carol. | |||
|
|
| #22 | |||
| Total Fan Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 7,069
| i dont' like a suicidal girlfriend, but that has nothing to do with addison. derek cheated on addison, but that has nothing to do with mer being suicidal. i think her point is, they can be mutually exclusive. it doesn't always have to me mer did this, well addison did this. why can't we just not like what mer did without draggin other people into it? __________________ when a lady walks up 2 me and says, "hey do you know what's sexy" i say "no but i can add up all the change in your purse very fast | |||
|
|
| #23 | |||
| Master Fan Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 11,666
| Quote:
__________________ even if things end up a bit too heavy | |||
|
|
| #24 | |||
| Master Fan Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,342
| I hate the suicide but I don't judge Meredith. She had an horrible life and a terrible mother. Ellis words killed her and she was alone. I don't know the depression but I'm glad that she choose to live for herself, Derek and Cristina. She has another possibility. I think the script was extreme for this reason. | |||
|
|
| #25 | |||
| Moderator Support Team   | There's no reason to compare Addison and Meredith since what they did are both extremely different things. And Addison wasn't the only one who 'cheated', Derek did the exact same. I think we need to keep Addison out of this thread once and for all when it comes to comparing Addison and Meredith. Quote:
 But he does smile in a few ones.. I have like 18 patrick icons and also a ton of Meredith icons..  __________________ || Come Visit Us @ Matt Czuchry's forum || | |||
|
|
| #26 | |||
| Total Fan Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 7,069
| i can imagine how many sad ones you have. him outside ellis' room. UGH. that was rough. did you do one of him looking at ellis? __________________ when a lady walks up 2 me and says, "hey do you know what's sexy" i say "no but i can add up all the change in your purse very fast | |||
|
|
| #27 | |||
| Master Fan Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 12,922
| Maybe we need a Meredith vs. Addison thread. . . . . . Kidding! I'm just kidding!  Can't wait to see your icons either Karen!  __________________ Visit the 90's Board! | |||
|
|
| #28 | |||
| Moderator Support Team | I have 2 I think of him looking at Ellis..  I'll post them in a few minutes.. All 79 are done!! Tomorrow GG icons and then I'm done __________________ || Come Visit Us @ Matt Czuchry's forum || | |||
|
|
| #29 | |||
| Master Fan Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 19,342
| We talked about this in many posts and I don't want to reopen this discussion. Addison's adultery changed Derek's life forever. The comparison isn't strange: suicide girlfriend/cheated wife. Cute icons un_den_iable: 317 Icons | |||
|
|
| #30 | |||
| Total Fan Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 7,069
| ooh karen, good. i can't wait, and hmmm matty in grey pants. i'll have to check those out when u are done. __________________ when a lady walks up 2 me and says, "hey do you know what's sexy" i say "no but i can add up all the change in your purse very fast | |||
|
|
  |
| Thread Tools | |||||||
| |||||||
| |
