Matt Czuchry - ♥ Sophies #18 ♥ ~ Because their love only happens 'Once in a Lifetime'! - Page 16

AlwaysHoldingOn · 09-21-2007, 04:57 PM

maybe it wasn't the right time, but I dont like the way Rory rephrased her reasonto say no.

Well Lorelai raised her didn't she?

she's the one to blame

**Eternal Flame** · 09-22-2007, 02:48 AM

you just like to put blame on all people but Logan

I don't have much problems with Rory's speech.

**autumnღfairytale** · 09-22-2007, 04:44 AM

Quote:

Well Lorelai raised her didn't she?

she's the one to blame

I can't agree so. I think it's the easy way to blame Lorelai for everything that happened. I know a lot fans blame her for nothing saying anything to Rory after the proposal. But when you have doubts doubts, and she had them ( And she has every right to have doubts. Even if she likes him now or not. It was kind of rushed and everything) sLorelai had also could have said to Rory that she don't think they should get married. Instead she said nothing and it was only on Rory to decide if she is ready for that step or not.

**Eternal Flame** · 09-22-2007, 04:46 AM

I agree Jess

and Lorelai only voiced her opinion after Rory had made her decision which IMO was the best way to go for Lorelai.

**autumnღfairytale** · 09-22-2007, 04:56 AM

Quote:

and Lorelai only voiced her opinion after Rory had made her decision which IMO was the best way to go for Lorelai.

It definitely was!

She knew that this time her opinion didn't matter. Should she Have lied to Rory? I don't think so. Not saying anything was the best she could do.

**Eternal Flame** · 09-22-2007, 05:01 AM

I'm not sure if Lorelai had said 'marry him', if it would come off as believable.. and if Lorelai had said 'don't marry him' it probably would end up in an argument of why and doubt in Rory's mind.

**autumnღfairytale** · 09-23-2007, 02:16 AM

Quote:

and if Lorelai had said 'don't marry him' it probably would end up in an argument of why and doubt in Rory's mind.

I think If Lorelai had said don't marry him Rory and Lorelau would have fight.They would have had a agrument that although Lorelai said she is okay with him she never really accepted him in her daughters life. Maybe after that Rory had said yes. Really I can see this that she does that just because Lorelai was another time against him. And that wouldn't have been right, to say yes to Logan when she has doubt only because she want to show Lorelai that no matter what she is thinking that Logan is a part of her life and that Lorelai can't change the fact.

**Eternal Flame** · 09-23-2007, 05:17 AM

I think Rory would have said 'Yes' for the wrong reasons yes, so in all in all it's good that Lorelai didn't say a thing.

**autumnღfairytale** · 09-23-2007, 05:21 AM

Quote:

I think Rory would have said 'Yes' for the wrong reasons yes, so in all in all it's good that Lorelai didn't say a thing.

We agree a lot lately Karen, it's almost scary

And with that yes their relationhip wouldn't have ended good either, I'm sure about that.

**Eternal Flame** · 09-23-2007, 05:24 AM

It's the 'Twilight Zone'

Maybe it's our lucky week Jess..

If Logan had found out about Rory and Lorelai's argument and what it would be about, I don't think it would be good for their relationship either.. Logan would be mad that she said 'yes' for the wrong reasons, to prove her mother wrong.. and not because of the reasons why one would say yes.
That definitely has fic potential btw.

**autumnღfairytale** · 09-23-2007, 05:30 AM

Quote:

If Logan had found out about Rory and Lorelai's argument and what it would be about, I don't think it would be good for their relationship either.. Logan would be mad that she said 'yes' for the wrong reasons, to prove her mother wrong.. and not because of the reasons why one would say yes.
That definitely has fic potential btw.

Exactly my thoughts

Great fic potential. I have to think about it

Better a honest 'no' as a 'yes' with the wrong reaons

**Eternal Flame** · 09-23-2007, 05:35 AM

the first time I'm able to see your icon is in it thread, and I see that you have a Lit icon.. The irony..

Yes Jess write a fic!

I want to read one of yours,

Quote:

Better a honest 'no' as a 'yes' with the wrong reaons

Well said

Now that no doesn't sound as bad no.. Well a yes for the right reasons of course always sounds better

**autumnღfairytale** · 09-23-2007, 06:23 AM

Quote:

the first time I'm able to see your icon is in it thread, and I see that you have a Lit icon.. The irony..

Sorry but the icon won't last long

Quote:

Yes Jess write a fic! I want to read one of yours

It will happen someday, I'll promise

Quote:

Now that no doesn't sound as bad no.. Well a yes for the right reasons of course always sounds better

In this situation it was, if we are honest, the best she could do. She wasn't ready to marry him

We just have to accept this. I have no problem with the fact that Logan walked away, he as hurted but a come back from him later after he thought abouteverythign would have been good. As good as a fighting Rory.

**Eternal Flame** · 09-23-2007, 06:26 AM

I'll hold you to that promise Jess

Quote:

Sorry but the icon won't last long

There's another one coming?! Cool!

Quote:

We just have to accept this. I have no problem with the fact that Logan walked away, he as hurted but a come back from him later after he thought abouteverythign would have been good. As good as a fighting Rory.

Well IMO that could still happen..

Tough it may be more difficult with Rory on the road, and Logan not knowing where she is exactly.

**autumnღfairytale** · 09-23-2007, 06:28 AM

Quote:

Tough it may be more difficult with Rory on the road, and Logan not knowing where she is exactly.

To see that he at least tried would be okay with me. And Lorelai could Logan tell where she is...another sucide mission never hurts.

But I doubt that Logan would be strong enough to find Rory.