Mischa Barton - OT #199: Jack Shepherd > life. - Page 5

CreekFreak · 05-02-2008, 12:24 PM

The lies are what is eating Jack up inside. His journey has been the most interesting, imo. Followed by Des.

your_konstantine · 05-02-2008, 01:17 PM

Quote:

When Hobo!Jack! and Kate met at the airport they were still in love with each other and almost kissed.

Correction: He was still in love with her, and he almost kissed her. I think her feelings were made pretty clear when she got the hell out of there before that sketchy beard got anywhere near her.

Quote:

Jack/Kate's "problems" don't even TOUCH Skate's lack of compatibility.

LOL. I would HARDLY put problems in quotations,as if the fact that their relationship has serious issues is a rash over-exaggeration. That last scene proved that they lack trust and honesty...which are two of the most important aspects of a relationship.

Quote:

Spoiler:

Also, maybe we should spend time insulting Kate, who doesn't even give a **** that Sawyer is still on the island, EVEN WHEN HOBO!JACK! wants to go back! Oh, yeah, and she started a serious relationship with Jack and accepted his proposal. OH THE EPIC LOVE SHE HAS FOR SAWYER.

I'll start insulting Kate once I see how Sawyer and Kate left things on that island. I don't think it makes sense to start judging a character before I know how the two of them left things. There's also such thing as DENIAL,which Kate is clearly in. That argument between J/K at the end seemed to me that Jack is well aware that Sawyer still is, and always will be, a factor,and he's trying to reiterate to her that Sawyer chose the island over her, so she should choose him over Sawyer.

And I don't understand how the island is the only reason things aren't working between Jack and Kate. If they were back on the island,everything would be all dandy and peachy? Because if I remember correctly,she had plenty of chances to get her **** together with Jack on the island,and she never did. She always found her way back to Sawyer.

Anyway,I'm clearly not going to convince you one way and you're not going to convince me the other. But I truly thought the episode last night was a major dissappointment. Where was the big reveal or twist? The only interesting part was Jin/Charlotte/Dan and Sawyer/Claire/Miles/Christian.

CreekFreak · 05-02-2008, 01:30 PM

Skate have nothing close to trust or honesty, so trying to claim that they do while Jate don't is wildly incorrect.

I don't get why you want to hold off insulting Kate when she started a serious relationship with Jack and accepted a MARRIAGE PROPOSAL. That doesn't make her fickle to you? Or does it not matter what she does as long as she ends up with Sawyer in the end?

Sawyer was a very tiny part of that argument. Jack is sick of the lies. The fight wasn't about Kate choosing Jack over Sawyer or vice versa.

Yes, she found her way back to Sawyer on the island to screw and argue. That relationship is so freaking great!

I'm also not going to convince you, but doing this back and forth thing is pointless. You know we're Jate fans, as we know you love Skate. It's a waste of time.

**Cristofle** · 05-02-2008, 03:53 PM

There shouldn't be a big reveal or twist about the show in every episode. That would make the show a string of stunts strung together, and the feeling that they were doing just that is why I stopped watching in S3. This was a more character look at the two main characters years into the future (and for me, given that I watch Jack scenes, it gave their show's best asset in Matthew Fox more to do than he's had all season). And the twist was that they'd gotten together, which given the meltdown one way or the other I've seen online was a pretty successful twist in terms of getting buzz, lol.

~Melissa~ · 05-02-2008, 05:22 PM

JATE IS FATE. e

**Shining Light** · 05-02-2008, 05:47 PM

Quote:

Pleas tell me I'm not the only one who ship Skate here

You're not, I do too, as does Amy.

We're a minority bunch.

There's a Jate kiss? Oh christ almighty.

Remind me not to watch that ep, I don't particularly want to make my eyes bleed.

~Melissa~ · 05-02-2008, 05:55 PM

LMAO. Cat, Jate is the only ship we don't agree on. I guess I can forgive you, lol. I mean, you love Huddy and Booth/Brennan.

**Shining Light** · 05-02-2008, 06:18 PM

Quote:

I guess I can forgive you, lol. I mean, you love Huddy and Booth/Brennan.

I'm glad.

There's those two and Harry/Hermione too, so I can look past the Jate thing in your case.

~Melissa~ · 05-02-2008, 06:20 PM

HHr! Love!

**Shining Light** · 05-02-2008, 06:36 PM

Quote:

HHr! Love!

Exactly.

Epilogue? What epilogue?

I'd almost rather have had Harry wind up dead than with that Ginny bitch though.

your_konstantine · 05-02-2008, 08:38 PM

LOL, I'm really,really tired, so the first time I read that, I saw "I'd almost rather have had Harry wind up with Dean than with that Ginny bitch."

LOL. I love Dean,he's so fabulous.

~Melissa~ · 05-02-2008, 08:40 PM

LMAOOOoo. Amy.

mjgchick · 05-02-2008, 08:48 PM

Melissa I thought your icon was moving LMAO

Aww Natasha Betingfield is on Chelsea Lately

**Cristofle** · 05-02-2008, 08:50 PM

I TOTALLY would have rather Harry have ended up with Dean. It's unfortunate they had tension over worthless Ginny. Bros over hos, dude.

CreekFreak · 05-02-2008, 08:51 PM

For anyone who cares, Dempsey is on Letterman tonight. Which is in a few minutes!