[heartღaflutter]

ah that's a shame

though I do love Raining Men!! She did such a great job on that song

I surrender is amazing too given she was sick!! I love that version too!

I truly think all the songs from this point on were pretty amazing!! Think Twice is great as is Without You!!

[shinebrighterxx]

At least I can get them back so far but a shame they've been disappearing between when I collected them at the start of the month & when I go to post the weekly bits

Still need to watch them from last week

[heartღaflutter]

it's stupid

You should catch up! I'm up to date

[shinebrighterxx]

I know, I really need to. I should do that tomorrow

[heartღaflutter]

and did you?

[shinebrighterxx]

No. Of course not


Don't Play That Song shows some nice vocals & notes but isn't the most interesting song. Plus I'm not sure on the backing singers? I've never been a fan of backing vocals on reality shows though - find they can get distracting & take away from being able to actually judge the singer based on their voice . The performance finished better than how it started

I'm the opposite to you I think as I love Stuff Like That There. I think she did amazing with it & she seemed to have some fun with it. But then DPTS did showcase her vocals more probably

Walk on By is the best of those three though


Kelly's 'Its Raining Men' version isn't bad but I've heard a lot better & it could've been better & showed off her vocals more. I also kinda felt she seemed a little awkward in it more than owning it? At least compared to other performances she's done? But supposedly she was sick this week? They don't say anything, it just mentions it in the comments on the videos?

But then I Surrender is incredible - then this one they say her voice was strained & she had no voice? Were both in the same week or night?

Think Twice was good but preferred I Surrender . Love Without You more, possible more than I Surrender. She's also crazy singing great singers who really shouldn't be touched & then knocking them out of the park

[heartღaflutter]

I do think Walk on By is the better on of the first 3 yes

But then I Surrender is incredible - then this one they say her voice was strained & she had no voice? Were both in the same week or night?

I think so, I think they did 2 performances a show around this time

yeah she shots a lot of guts going with songs from Celine, Whitney and Aretha...

[shinebrighterxx]

If there was the two then that makes more sense to what I was reading then

Obviously not all her choice but she took the challenge & amazed with them

[heartღaflutter]

Pretty impressive that she dared to do it

[shinebrighterxx]

R e w a t c h i n g  A m e r i c a n  I d o l
S e a s o n O n e  P e r f o r m a n c e s

March 29th - April 4th

Finale:
"A Moment Like This"
"Respect"
"Before Your Love"
Winning Performance "A Moment Like This"

[heartღaflutter]

Winning performance of AMLT is better than the first one, I love the emotions in the winning moment one

Respect is awesome!

She did an amazing job with Before your love as well

[shinebrighterxx]

I hadn't seen the first performance of AMLT before. I really like it but yes the emotions in the winning performance will always be better I think. Just gives the song so much more meaning I think too

She shows so much confidence & comfort during the Respect performance

BYL really allowed her to play around & find/show off what her voice could do. The song isn't a stand out song for me but that performance was really good as were her vocals on it

[heartღaflutter]

her vocals were really strong overall IMO during AI with a few performances that were a little less solid but the emotion of AMLT is amazing... It still makes me cry sometimes if i haven't seen it in a long time

[heartღaflutter]

Planning a Wrapped in Red listening party in the WiR thread!! Just a FYI

[kiss the wind]

Thanks, Karen!