stlavin95

Yeah I kinda hated that as well, but it was way more annoying when they did that with Brooke.

rossfangirl86

Petra, I enjoyed that episode/scene as well. Peyton/Nathan changed a lot as people and i like that this episode acknowledged that as well as the relationship they had before. And how it changed.

stlavin95

Nathan definitely did change as an character, but I felt their developed his character too far and took everything way that made him an interesting character imo.

Slayerette89

Tbh, I don't think he was ever an interesting character. That whole resident transformed poor little dumb rich jock bully thing could have been more watchable if he had any charisma and if he was better written. But imo neither of those two was ever the case. I did like him around Peyton, but I was indifferent to him otherwise.

Lol, fair enough. He might not have even written that ep. But I blame everything on him regardless

stlavin95

Mark did actually write the episode haha. I think James' acting and the writing were to blame for why Nathan was giving Jake an run for his money for the most boring main character on the show.

rossfangirl86

At one point I liked Nathan more than Lucas (s3) so I can't say I agree with you guys. But the marriage storyline really didn't do a lot for his character. That's why I liked seeing him in scenes with Peyton, we got to see another side of him.

Should we use a quote from the gif-set on the last page for our next title? We're almost there.

stlavin95

I liked Nathan the most in S1 so that's probably why I see it that way lol. Yeah we can use that I guess.

rossfangirl86

I liked him in s1, s2, s3, and parts of s4. They kind of lost me after the time jump.

stlavin95

I still liked him in those seasons, I just think he was an pretty boring after S1 and especially S4.

rossfangirl86

He had potential as a character but they didn't ultize him as much as they could've.

stlavin95

Yeah agreed.

Alexa

I always found Nathan pretty boring. i do think he was the most interesting in seasons 1-3 but i think james got bored of the role. lol. I enjoyed some of the "funny" nathan stuff in the later seasons but wow, he was pretty dull as a character and had nothing that significant going on except basketball.

stlavin95

Yeah agreed The writers should have given him more storylines outside of basketball and his family.

Summer Falls

Lol im alway the opposite to everyone lol i lived nathan again i do agree he was limitted in what his role was basketball or hayley .. wished he had more sceens with everyone else ..

I honestly enjoyed him more than lucas .. lucas to me was the worst one s1 he was ok ths he just tot so boring

stlavin95

How was Luke boring? He maybe have been douchy at times but he was way more interesting than Nathan ever was.