Alexa

i love that they are still friends, they are so sweet.

i thought about what if sophia played peyton and hilarie played brooke, would i still ship lP or not and its hard to say because i do love the storyline for LP in season 1 so much but i think if i had seen BL (aka hilarie and chad) together in season i probably woulda switched teams because i woulda loved their chemistry together.

stlavin95

It depends on whether storylines stay the same or not. Plus I'm not sure whether Sophia could have played an great Peyton.

Slayerette89

I'm wondering about that too. I love LP story potential, especially in s1. But I never liked Sophia/Chad on screen, so I'm not sure I could have gotten past that.

stlavin95

Yeah, I'm not sure whether Chad and Sophia would have sold LP's story since I don't think they that type of chemistry.

Summer Falls

I love sophia but her as peyton would be werid i think it wouldn't work expecially of the same thing happen with the actors getting married would of been super awkward of they played P & L i think they woild have ruined that relationship

Slayerette89

Good point. We probably wouldn't have had BL in s2, given CS wouldn't have been pushing for it. But after the divorce, they still wouldn't have wanted anything to do with each other.

stlavin95

Yeah I definitely wouldn't be against no BL in season 2 haha.

LeytonForEver!

stlavin95

No BL/JP would have improved that season a lot for me.

LeytonForEver!

I bet. For me too.

stlavin95

It definitely would have avoided a lot of the issues I had with S2.

LeytonForEver!

Maybe it would have created some other issues with another season.

stlavin95

Like what season?

LeytonForEver!

Whichever, you know the butterfly effect.

rossfangirl86

Can't imagine Hil playing Brooke. It just feels weird to think about. And I'm sure the character would've been different since she's a different actress. Not sure if she would've been as bubbly if Hil had played her and not sure what BL would've looked like with CH playing them.