Sophia Bush - Brooke♥Lucas #41 ~ There's No Moving On, Cause I Know You're The One. And I Can't Be Without You. - Page 6

samanta · 06-04-2009, 11:34 AM

Yeah, I know. Seriously those episodes make my day better.

Today I actually became all sentimental and sad watching the show, bc it was such a different show. It felt like a whole different show. I enjoy every moment of the whole episode, even Peyton´s scenes, bc it just draws you in. I still like and sometimes love the show but it´s definitely changed, and I think it will become a whole other show for s 7

CheEsecAKe&BRUCAS · 06-04-2009, 04:53 PM

The show's atmosphere completely changed in season 4. Granted, it also shifted in s2, but it was subtle and had more lead in. Season 4 on was just...WTF happened?

Scheming Star · 06-04-2009, 05:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brucas4life (View Post)

That's what gets me so angry, you can't rewrite history and change things just to suit the direction you now decide you want to go in. It's terrible writing. And imo you shouldn't have to put down another relationship/couple in order to boost another one. It doesn't make people rethink and go oh actually I was wrong and I'm going to ship LP now, it just makes the fans mad and if anything increase their dislike of them. They don't understand the fans at all.

Oh yeah I know. It sucks that season two and three shows the actual feeling of Lucas toward Brooke, and then all of sudden, his feeling disappeared like that. As if he hasn't never been in love with her, but Peyton?! That's a big WTF for all of us, definitely. It's pretty obvious that seasons were leading us on for nothing, but to trash them, destroy them, betray all of us, just to make LP happen in the end. That sucks. I honestly dont get it because when NH were together and all, I am sure Nathan dreamt about Haley in season two around the time she was on the tour, he still dreamt about her, wanting her, etc, and now NH are back together and happier than ever, so Lucas did exact same thing by dreaming about Brooke, and yet he claims to be in love with Peyton, but not Brooke? I don't get it.

samanta · 06-05-2009, 11:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CheEsecAKe&BRUCAS (View Post)

The show's atmosphere completely changed in season 4. Granted, it also shifted in s2, but it was subtle and had more lead in. Season 4 on was just...WTF happened?

Yes, I agree. I can´t stand that season - not even bc of the LP stuff, well maybe it has something to do with it, but it was just so WTF as you say. Everything was upside down.

Scheming Star · 06-05-2009, 11:28 AM

^Yep, I agree.

B.Davis-Baker · 06-05-2009, 12:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CheEsecAKe&BRUCAS (View Post)

The show's atmosphere completely changed in season 4. Granted, it also shifted in s2, but it was subtle and had more lead in. Season 4 on was just...WTF happened?

I stopped watching season 4 because I got mad about that. I was like okay how can you write that someone's feelings just disappeared as if they were never there. How do you just pretend like it never happened? In my opinion season 4 never happened because I never watched it. The only episodes I ever watched from it was the first one and Nathan, Skills, and Mouths striptease. LOL I tuned back in during season 5 because I was interested in the time jump and how it would work and I was happy with some of the Brucas scenes but then I realized they were just scraps to keep us content. I kept watching season 6 because I like Austin Nichols.

To be honest I think Austin was cast to tear up Peyton and Lucas but then they realized that Chad and Hil probably wouldn't be coming back if there was a season 7 and decided to rewrite Julian so that Mark could keep Leyton together.

samanta · 06-05-2009, 12:49 PM

I don´t get why he wrote that Honey Grove episode that way he did -when Brooke walked in on LP in bed she was clearly hurt and sad and heartbroken - and yet they ignored that for the rest of the season, as if it was just whatever. As if she never had any feelings for him and Chase was her true love

Scheming Star · 06-05-2009, 12:57 PM

^Yeah I know.

I honestly dont get it either.

They want to make it look like Brooke is totally okay and cool with whole LP thing I guess. I know that sucks the most but that's what season four was all about.

samanta · 06-05-2009, 01:00 PM

Yeah....Urgh....

Scheming Star · 06-05-2009, 01:02 PM

Yeah you can tell from it!

Like whole basketball champsion thing when Brooke said, "It's okay, it's OKAY! Go to her" kinda gave away that they are making her act like it's OKAY that they hook up even in front of her because she is fine and all.

B.Davis-Baker · 06-05-2009, 02:09 PM

I think the best example of her not being completely okay with it is her crying during Lucas and Peyton's wedding. I mean they could probably excuse it has tears of happiness or she was sad that everyone was getting love but her but she had Julian offering her love and everyone else was laughing and joking while she was crying.

**BA4eva** · 06-05-2009, 02:23 PM

New thread and i'm only posting here now

the title!

CheEsecAKe&BRUCAS · 06-05-2009, 07:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by samanta (View Post)

I don´t get why he wrote that Honey Grove episode that way he did -when Brooke walked in on LP in bed she was clearly hurt and sad and heartbroken - and yet they ignored that for the rest of the season, as if it was just whatever. As if she never had any feelings for him and Chase was her true love

Tell me about it.

I really don't understand why Mark continuously had Brooke show that she still loved Lucas and yet he expects us to believe that 408 was closure for them? It just...it wasn't handled well AT ALL. Then again, many things aren't handled that well or realistically on OTH. Keith's death, Naley marriage, Naley baby, Brooke's parent's storyline..the only thing that was given specific detail to were Peyton's storylines...and oh man I was disappointed at how easily Lucas got over Dan shooting Keith thing. Seriously, it would take a LONG time for a kid to get over that.

It's a wonder why I stuck with this show. Hang on...I didn't. Never mind.

samanta · 06-06-2009, 04:30 AM

Yeah, exactly. I feel like the first 2 seasons and the first half of season 3, were the best, hell even the other half of s 3, if you take away the shooting episode and how they handled the death or Keith. But s4, it just went downhill. Season 5 felt a bit like the old OTH. But all the new people annoyed me.

Brucas4life · 06-06-2009, 08:46 AM

Aw I love that cap