Sophia Bush - 5.17 'Hate is Safer than Love' Episode Discussion.

**-Beautiful Disaster-** · 05-12-2008, 03:54 PM

Lucas (Chad Michael Murray) is crushed by devastating news, while Brooke's (Sophia Bush) baby undergoes emergency surgery.

Haley (Bethany Joy Galeotti) wrestles with her decision to record a new album.

Skills (Antwon Tanner) and Nathan (James Lafferty) employ a risky game plan to salvage the Raven's season and Lucas stuns Peyton (Hilarie Burton) with a shocking truth.

Lee Norris also stars. Stuart Gillard directed the episode written by Mark Schwahn.

_Jmarit_ · 05-12-2008, 07:18 PM

Dude

I am all for Brooke and hot doctor dude.

BA was amazing. Pure love.

ashleymarie · 05-12-2008, 07:24 PM

I loved Brooke in tonights episode, how worried and concerned she was for her baby was just the sweetest thing I've ever seen.

Sophia always impresses me with her scenes, especially tonight. She really let the emotion out in her scenes and I believed what her character was going through, which made me want to cry as well. The way she pulled those tears out was amazing, not alot of people that force out emotions like that but she pulled it off.. which was just great.

_Jmarit_ · 05-12-2008, 07:34 PM

I agree. She's so amazing at being emotional. Everytime she cries i feel like crying with her.

B.Scott · 05-12-2008, 07:37 PM

I can't wait to see it, but pls no new love interest for Brooke AGAIN

_Jmarit_ · 05-12-2008, 08:18 PM

But hot doctor dude is so cute!!

I'd actually like them

Surprising.

*Lucie* · 05-13-2008, 03:03 AM

I really liked this episode!

Brooke was amazing once more!!

Her scenes with Angie were great we can really see how much she loves that little girl!

There were BL scenes again

they weren't as cute as in the previous episodes but still we got a hug

The doctor dude makes me think of Chase, all I hope is that he won't go out with her, I'm tired of seeing her with so many different guys!
I could like him if he were THE one. But that's what I thought with Owen and it didn't happen so I don't know what to think of the guy.
I don't really want him to stay!

I looved the end

maybe that's hope for BL

brooke had emotional scens and once again Sophia rocks those! She was awesome!!

She made me cry

samanta · 05-13-2008, 05:30 AM

I thought that this episode was kind of boring too.

The one thing I did love was the BL and BA scenes. They were heartbreaking. To see Brooke cry like that - makes you wanna cry without a doubt. She is so amazing when it comes to scenes like that.

And that baby is the cutest thing ever. How she put her little hand on Brooke´s mouth when she was about to give her for surgery was beyond cute, and seemed very much unscripted.

I of course loved that Lucas was there for her through the whole thing and didn´t even want to leave, even though he had a big game and then also came after it

Even though he was so upset.

I felt so bad for him when he told Nathan that Lindsay is seeing someone else. My heart broke out for him. And I honestly think it´s stupid that Lindsay even called him just to tell him that . And on game night. What did she expect from him? That he´d be excited for her? I really think it was a lousy move on her part.

And the way he was breaking apart - it was definitely one of Chad´s better scenes, and I usually don´t even think his scenes are that good. So hats off to him.

The IHY scene wasn´t as good as I expected it to be, honestly. I don´t like Peyton and I dislike LP very much but I did feel bad for her in that moment.
Especially knowing what the title of the episode is, and that it´s about him saying IHY to Peyton, it´s kind of bittersweet that he says it, when we know that it´s maybe easier to hate her than let himself love her again and be hurt, and I hate that. I didn´t even see the episodes title until now, which made me regret even watching the I hate you scene

Anyways the Haley stuff was kinda boring too. Nothing new there. Nathan and Jaime were

and Nathan was funny at times.

Deb/Skillz is ridiculous. She could be his mother.

And Mouth once again proved what a great friend he is

Gotta love him!

B.Scott · 05-13-2008, 07:51 AM

I thought the epi was ok.

Loved Brooke, but Lucas was very lame.

And when Brooke said that she wanted to be there when the baby opens her eyes I had to lol bc they put that ugly doll there

ashleymarie · 05-13-2008, 10:21 AM

Ethan is a pretty hot doctor.. but I don't think that Brooke needs a love interest at the moment, but it's possible..

I agree with you Azra, Lucas was lame.. what else is new with him?

**Miranda** · 05-13-2008, 10:22 AM

I loved this episode! I so feel for Brooke, when she cried it made me cry too.. Sophia really rocked those scenes, she is so good at them and

another BL hug! though I was bummed that they didn't have more scene but I was very glad with the ones we did get..

and OMG did you guys see the promo for the season finale?!

ashleymarie · 05-13-2008, 10:25 AM

^ I saw the promo, quite shocking.. Like wow!! Can't wait.

***Stephie*** · 05-13-2008, 11:23 AM

Can't wait to see the eppy

Brooke seemed to be amazing again

**~Leonie~** · 05-13-2008, 11:28 AM

lucas.....pretty lame

I mean, I kinda felt sorry for him...although I thought something really terrible would happen when I read the spoilers..and this is not that terrible

PH

I loved them together

especially with the balloon
and P. made me live 'you have too much to life for'

Brooke made me cry again

and the doctor is hot

Deb/Skills eww eww eww eww eww eww, Deb really didn't change

ashleymarie · 05-13-2008, 11:43 AM

^ Gotta agree with you on Deb/Skills.. talk about completly unexpected yet creepy at the same time. Like what the hell was that makeout session all about?