Bethany Joy - Haley/Brooke #5: Things change, but seasons later, these roomies are still going strong, still there for anything! - Page 20

**UDflyer** · 11-07-2009, 12:16 PM

Oops. We were posting at the same time, Elsa. LOL.

Updated post count:

#11 - 4
#13 - 2

LHScott · 11-07-2009, 01:04 PM

#11 - 5
#13 - 2

same old story · 11-07-2009, 01:12 PM

Um, this is a travisty. My mind does not compute. Well, I mean, given this is the Joy board, and I get why people that are Haley fans before anything else (which I am too, actually), wouldn't like that scene ... Yeah, I don't know, still doesn't compute. I think it's adorable. It isn't my ultimate favorite, but WAY better than half the scenes that are still left, anyway. Like 13. All about boys. Don't curr.

11 - 5
13 - 3

LHScott · 11-07-2009, 01:21 PM

^ It's not just about being a Haley fan before all else (well for me anyways), because I would still vote for it if the roles were reversed. The be the girl I love and the hug is adorable but the cheating storyline is one of the worst storylines for me. I also don't like that Rachel took away from BH after S3 and that generally in S4 Haley was neglected by mostly everyone, this storyline didn't help

. Just my two cents.

Ms. · 11-07-2009, 01:24 PM

11 - 6
13 - 3

It's not that I don't like the scene, it just doesn't stand out as much for me as the others that are left.

**More Than That** · 11-07-2009, 01:26 PM

11 - 6
13 - 4

Scheming Star · 11-07-2009, 01:27 PM

cmba310 · 11-07-2009, 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by same old story (View Post)

Like 13. All about boys. Don't curr.

Was #13 about boys...in terms of BH that is? I don't recall that. I thought it was a really fun/funny start to BH. I recall Peyton and Haley talking about boys, but not BH. Hmm....

Not that it would be my #1 choice in the survivor, but I just don't recall it being heavily related to boys. Then again, its been a while since I watched any S1.

**killed the lights** · 11-07-2009, 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by same old story (View Post)

Um, this is a travisty. My mind does not compute. Well, I mean, given this is the Joy board, and I get why people that are Haley fans before anything else (which I am too, actually), wouldn't like that scene ... Yeah, I don't know, still doesn't compute. I think it's adorable. It isn't my ultimate favorite, but WAY better than half the scenes that are still left, anyway.

The scene is cute if you take out of context everything happened before. BH hugging it out, deff cute. The stealing test storyline was not cute, at all. And not only did Brooke steal a test using Haley's copied key, but when Haley got fired for it, Brooke waited FOREVER to tell Haley it was her that took it, and not Rachel. Season 4 was just a debacle all together, especially for BH.

**joypiter** · 11-07-2009, 02:18 PM

BH Fav Moment Survivor

#11 - 7
#13 - 4

Round #25

Vote for your least favorite moment. We'll eliminate the moment first to reach 7 vote(s)or after 9 people have voted.
Note-Number for elimination subject to change depending on participation.

#1 - Eliminated in Round 1

H-What are you watching?
B-I don’t know but they seem sad.
H-Did you talk to Lucas? Sorry. We’d we go so wrong?
B-Well…I slept with Chris Keller and you went on tour with him.
H-No, I mean- ok yeah. But when did we start letting boys dictate our happiness?
B-I was nine.
H-Well I don’t care, it has to stop. You have too much talent with your fashion line.
B-Not anymore.
H-Oh so what they stole a couple of designs. They didn’t steal your talent. I’m sure you got more.
B-A couple of unfinished dresses.
H-So finish them. Listen- we’ll put together a website and we’ll sell them ourselves.
B-And you’d help me?
H-Yeah, I’d help you. But you have to help yourself first missy.
B-Clothes over bro’s?
H-Clothes over bro’s.

#3 - Eliminated in Round 7

#4 - Eliminated in Round 20

#5 - Eliminated in Round 17

#6 - Eliminated in Round 16

#7 Eliminated in Round 6
#1 - Eliminated in Round 1

#9 - Eliminated in Round 15

#10 - Eliminated in Round 21

#11 - Eliminated in Round 24

B- What are you doing? The band is playing, you’re missing it.
H- This is such a bad idea.
B- But Nathan totally talked to you. He swooped in like some sort of night in Batman armor.
H- That’s not the point. I look like an idiot.
B- Ok maybe now that you’ve messed up your hair.
H- This whole thing is a lie. You turn into some spandex wearing cigarette smoking hussy and you get your man. That doesn’t work.
B-You were smoking?
H- Even if it did- that’s not who I am. I’m a tutor, I’m a nerd.
B-You’re a rockstar.
H-Not anymore. I’m just Haley. That really should be enough. I’m done playing games, Brooke. I’m just going to go home.
B- Ok.
H-And there better be cookie dough.

B-What is your name?
H-Ha-ley.
B- Yeah, I don’t like that name. Let’s call you, Brooke.

Dialogue break

B-That’s perfect. Brooke you can come with us.
H-Yeah, she named me Brooke.
B- We’re going on a roadtrip.

B-Pretty good, huh?
H-Yeah. Hey, I don’t think you need the apostrophe though on Bros. It’s not really grammatically correct.
B-It’s my fashion line and I’m keeping the apostrophe.
H-Ok. Well good for you. You did it all yourself anyway.
B-Not really. You got me there.
H-Yeah, I kind of feel like a big fraud.
B-What? Why?
H-Because I told you to put yourself before boys and I secretly spent the whole day thinking about Nathan.
B--Why? Did something happen?
H-You know how I told you that Nathan kissed me at the masquerade party?
B-Yeah.
H-It might not have been Nathan. I think it might have been Chris.
B-Kringle? No, I didn’t think so. Wow! How could you kiss Chris Keller and then think that Chris was Nathan?
H-Maybe I just wanted to believe it was Nathan so bad…what if I was wrong though? He could just be trying to keep things pleasant until the divorce is final.
B-I do not believe that. I don’t. It’s hard isn’t it? I mean I love my clothes. But there’s an ache in my heart where Lucas used to be and -I don’t think covering it up with a stylish smartly priced sweat top going to make it go away.
H-It is stylish though.

#15 - Eliminated in Round 4

#16 - Eliminated in Round 12

B-Ok. Just think of it this way- most guys buy motorcycles because their compensating for you know. Nathan wears size 14’s
H-Oh thanks. I feel so much better now.

#17 - Eliminated in Round 22

H-Hey.
B- Hi Tutormom. How you feeling? You having fun or are you worried about the kid?
H- I am worried- about you, too. I’m going to miss you this summer.
B- Ok. Don’t- don’t do that. Don’t make me cry because I’m barely holding it together as it is.
H- Nathan and I want you to be James’s godmother.
B- Ok that’s going to do it. Haley. I would honored to be his godmother and I promise you that unlike my ungodly mother, I will so kickass at this.
H- I know you will- as long as you don’t say kickass around him too much.
B- Right, sorry.

#19 - Eliminated in Round 18

#20 - Eliminated in Round 10

B- Can I talk to you?
H- Uhh ok. Well, things are a little crazy right now.
B- Rachel caught me making maternity clothes
H-Brooke! On the list of people that know about this pregnancy I’m thinking Rachel really is not on the top of the list.
B- I know.
H- Ok. Well calm down. Does she suspect anything at all?
B- No. I don’t think so.
H- Ok. So it’s just you and me that knows. Let’s just keep it that way. It’s best. ok
B- I think I’d feel better if I didn’t even know about it.
H- It’s a little late for that, isn’t it? Did you and Lucas ever talk about what would happen if you…
B- Yeah. Last year, you know. He said he’d be there for me and the baby but I could tell he was scared and feeling trapped. He must’ve been frightened.
H- Yeah.
B- Did you and Nathan ever talk about it?
H-Yeah, don’t you remember? It was that night that we spent together . And then he found out I wasn’t on the pill, he freaked out. It was like the worst fight we ever had. Brooke, I got to get back out there. I’m sorry. It’s crazy and Deb’s out to lunch.
B- This is a awfully late lunch.
H- She’s here- she’s literally out to lunch. I’ll call you later.
B-Haley. It’s going to be ok, right?
H- Yeah Brooke it’s going to be ok. I hope.

#22 - Eliminated in Round 9

H-So considering I’m a honors student. How many years do you think I would get for stabbing someone-say Peyton with a giant fork.
B-Ok let’s not keep sharp objects around the house. I know that this whole thing with Nathan sucks for you. But right now I need your help bringing Rachel to her knees. Yes I know, it’s ironic. So here is my plan, I’m going to snipe her draft pick. She needs to know what it feels like when the shoe is up the other ass.
H- Ok what do you need from me? And do not say my shoes.
B- No. Rachel picks fifth. You pick fourth. I need you to pick Lucas so no one else gets him while I‘m screwing her over..
H- What about Bevin- she’s third.
B- Yeah, but she’s picking Skills.
H- Oh.
B-We got a deal?
H- Yeah well if I can’t have Nathan I may as well take Lucas. Deal.

H- I’m not sure that I can handle thinking of you and Lucas hooking up in the same room where I’m sleeping.
B-Lucas and/or others.
H-It’s a really good system. But I just really don’t think I’m going be needing any scrunchies anytime soon. B-Oh, no, no, roommate. Come here.

#25 - Eliminated in Round 13

#26 - Eliminated in Round 14

Coda

B- Hey
BH- I’m sorry.
B-I’m sorry. I was being selfish and I wasn’t listening to you.
H-I was so wrapped in what I wanted that dress to be that I freaked out a little bit. I would love to wear your dress.
B-That’s really nice. But I think you might want to save the love until after dinner tonight. You know all the questions I’ve been asking about the early days of Naley?
H-Yeah.
B-You didn’t really think I wanted to know all that stuff, did you?
H-Yes.
B-No. I was gathering material. See ya tonight.

#29 - Eliminated in Round 11
H- I’ll take one unfinished wedding dress. That’s all I want and I’ll pay top dollar for it.
B- Well I’ll pay top dollar for one song off of an unfinished album.
H- I don’t like this game anymore.
B- I feel ya.
H- So what’s going on with baby Brooke?

Dialogue break

H- Ahh. Have you thought about starting a new line, Brooke? You’ve done it before you can do it again.
B- I appreciate the vote of confidence Haley but, I’m just not feeling inspired lately.
H- Well speaking of- Owen looked pretty hot last night. Didn’t you think so Millie?
B- I think Sam is driving me crazy wilding about like a feral cat. Sam- this is a boutique, it is not a skate park. If you have a plan to fill this place up, have at it. Otherwise go skate in traffic.
H- Clearly I’ve upgraded Sam’s foster living environment.

Dialogue break

B- I would love that. It would be nice to have a man in the house.
H- And speaking of- I thought Owen looked pretty hot last night. Didn’t you think so Millie?
B- I think I don’t like either of you.

#30 - Eliminated in Round 5

#31 - Eliminated in Round 2

#32 - Eliminated in Round 23

#33 - Eliminated in Round 19

#34 - Eliminated in Round 8

LHScott · 11-07-2009, 02:29 PM

Thanks for the new round!

#21 - 1

cmba310 · 11-07-2009, 02:35 PM

Yeah, I could go for 21.

#21 - 2

-Caitlin- · 11-07-2009, 02:36 PM

#21 - 3

Pattt · 11-07-2009, 02:55 PM

I'm keeping my vote. lol

#13 - 1
#21 - 3

**PeytonMelissa** · 11-07-2009, 03:03 PM

#21 - 4