loppabelle

I think it gives Brooke something interesting and different as her role in those fics.

fly me to the moon

Yeah, that's true.. That made sense..

loppabelle

I love this scene.

fly me to the moon

Same here.. I think best season for them was second and third..

loppabelle

I love season 3 for them. I think that's when there relationship became the most grounded. I hated most season 4 because I feel like that became a Brooke I didn't like and that her head was turned for someone like Rachel at this he expense of Haley.Blah.

loppabelle

I love season 3 for them. I think that's when there relationship became the most grounded. I hated most season 4 because I feel like that became a Brooke I didn't like and that her head was turned for someone like Rachel at the expense of Haley.Blah.

fly me to the moon

Oh gosh, same here.. I hate how everything have to be about Brooke.. I was like sigh.. What we deserve to have this.. I could say same thing about Brooke/Peyton since everything about Brooke, never Peyton..

loppabelle

Well once again, I was' t on the BP train so I didn't really care. That friendship was kaput season 1. And all of those childhood memories were bs. LH were childhood friends too and they never would have done something so terrible to each other. LH may have had misguided ways of helping each other but that's it. And I still say that BP could've remained friends but I never bought that bs about them being besties. Nope. With friends like that, who needs enemies. And Rachel was the worst thing to happen to Brooke season 4, the season I like to call Mark's pure destruction of Brooke to make Peyton look good. If you notice Brooke took major steps backwards after she has grown so much. Lying, stealing, cheating, sex tape. It was all a plan to shine Peyton into a good light IMO. Too bad it was too late for many viewers.

fly me to the moon

I def agree w/ you about BP bec I never buy them being close plus who would go through like that plus my best friend and I best friend since we were like 8/9 years old, but we never being like that as what Brooke and Peyton did to each to her.. At least they should go w/ realistic as what they did w/ Pacey and Dawson when they decide not to being best friend no longer.. I feel like they going backward with both Brooke and Peyton because you can tell that whenever they did something forward then backward even tho both of them are screw up..

stlavin95

Breyton did suck as an friendship and that's on both parties imo. I never really felt S4 Brooke was out of character since she never really developed a lot before then, especially since she was rarely had an good friend to Peyton in the first three seasons and some of her worst moments as a character came in season 3 as well, so Mark didn't really need to make it her bad when she wasn't that great in the first place.

fly me to the moon

I agree.. I felt like both did wrong to each other and I hate how both act even tho I never understand why they willing to throw their friendship over dumb boy.. Even tho I felt like Brooke would be the one who walk away from Peyton even their friendship broken..

stlavin95

Yep, I don't like when people put Laley and Breyton since one is clearly a lot better than the other. Helped that other friendships didn't fall in love with the same guy like BP did.

fly me to the moon

Yeah, I totally agree w/ you on that.. Honestly, I have see that happen to one of my best friend and it's not the same even tho like you said, nothing can be same or move forward, so for BP, sure they moved out, but sound fake..

stlavin95

Didn't help that they both had no issues screwing the other over when it came to wanting Lucas.

fly me to the moon

Agree w/ you on that..