It must have been his 2nd past life then...or?

It wouldn't have worked.

Leo would be alive during his mortal life in that time period. Before he died and became a whitelighter. He couldn't have a past life at that same time. I think it was just a writing blooper (mistake) that they missed/didn't pay too much attention to. :shrug:

Yeah,must be because if he participated in WW2 then that life he had in the 20's episode must have been his real life.The one he lived for real.But how could he have been with Piper back then?I remember that he had a wife back then that Piper finds out about in one of the eps in S2.

Exactly.

In the 1920s, Leo probably still would have been a child/teenager. Then, he grew up and by the 1940s got married and then served in WWII. He couldn't have been with Piper's past self.

lol, Unless the writers wanted us to believe that Leo was like in his 40s when he served in WWII? And that he was in his 20's or early 30s in the 1920s. Then, he met someone else and married later on?

But the only thing that doesn't make sense about that is I believe the show was trying to say that was Leo in his past life. Which means he would be someone else. Not Leo during his mortal life. That's where the real confusion/problem comes in b/c that wouldn't make sense.

Yeah, it's really confusing but I must say that in 20's it was his mortal life and already in that he and Piper were soulmates and obviously involved before he married...

:shrug: Yeah, that's probably the best way to read into it!

Glad that we agree:nod:

:lol:
Yeah, well, when the writers mess up we viewers have to be creative! ;)

:lol:

Wow ... think about what this episode meant for Phoebe.

In her last life, she was evil. I wonder how her soul converted to the good side in her present life? Because ... as far as we know, she had no other lives in between that to work her way back to being good. Remember, like Paige? There was alot of time between that past her life as Paige. She could have had alot of lives to work it out.

Hmm, yeah that really doesn't make any sense really.How young must the sisters have been when they died if the would have had more lifes than 2 in the 1900s..:look:

Bring this up for more discussion

It was always leo/piper for me even though Dan was a really good guy.

:lol: Dan was a decent guy but I was always rooting for Leo/Piper too back in S2.

Also liked Leo and Piper together.