Charmed: Saddest scene or dialogue in the whole series?
 

I don't think there's a thread like this already but if there is: please merge or delete. :)

anyway, just like to know what is the saddest scene/s ( i have a lot) or dialogue/s for you in the whole series?

mine would be:

All Hell Breaks Loose - Piper's death scene, Holly and Shannen did a great job in that hospital scene, i have watched it countless of times. i'm just awed by their performance!

Morality Bites - the scene where Phoebe was explaining to her sisters why she must die... the chemistry from all three actresses was superb!

Charmageddon - the hope in Paige's face when she thought the Avatars could bring Kyle back, Rose was very good in that scene, and in the death scene of kyle in the "extreme makeover: world edition" episode

Hell Hath No Fury - Piper's grieving scene at Prue's tomb, blaming her sister for leaving her and begging her to come back... again one of holly's best in the series.

Deja Vu All Over Again - when Prue's one great love- Andy died, i felt the lost and grief too. :(

Sympathy for the Demon - the scene in the attic where cole got his powers back from Barbas and no one dared to thank him or comfort him and he just left... i felt so bad for him, that was really sad.

these are mine, what are yours?

i'm still re-watching the show... i might encounter more sadness...

I like the idea, I'm gonna check our board guide but otherwise keep posting :)

I also love the one in Vaya Con Leos.. "I have to lose you to save you"

Prue ' s funeral was heartbreaking. It made me cry everytime I have watched it. The song in the background is so sad.

Leo leaving Piper to become an elder.

When Cole died, and Phoebe was alone.

Andy's early death

My saddest moment
 

in Awakened

I always found the part where Piper dies really AMAZINGLY sad because they'd been fighting deamons for like 2 years and then suddenly it was something human and natural that killed her and they were powerless to stop it.

Also when Phoebe burnt in the Witch Trials, Holly Marie Combs's acting=FLAWLESS. I was in TEARS!

Also I write a Canon Season 3 based FanFic, please support if you can. <3

https://www.fanfiction.net/s/1007683...-Unholy-Spaces

wow awesome idea for a thread ok let me see

coles death was so sad both times - 2nd was his bday a little morbid
prues funeral - so sad piper killer it for me
andys death was just sad frist big character on teh show to actually die ( i wonder if it was planned or did the actor want ot leave? )
Hell Hath No Fury - yes piper again so sad

Piper at Prue's grave in season 4

Piper saying goodbye to Leo in season 8.

Cole's death.

So many sad moments! Definitely got to be Prue's funeral, Piper having to say goodbye to Leo in Vaya Con Leos and the finale made me cry 'cause it was the end but it was a happy ending.

oh yeah! the finale is sad/bittersweet, happy ending but still an ending, like you just wanna hold on the show. :(

I can't help but cry during Morality Bites. I think Phoebe's sacrifice was too pure

one sad dialogue/line i remember by heart:

"You asked me to marry you and I did. You wanted a family and I gave you a son. And now you want me to watch you just walk away? " - Piper (Oh My Goddess Pt 2)


:(

good quote :hug:

I cried when I watched "Vaya Con Leos" for the first time. I didn't want him to go away, even though he would come back at the end.

And the episode where Piper heals Leo, even though it was happy, it was still sad to me.

Absolutely love that song at the funeral too. Bell, book and candle by Eddi Reader :love:

http://38.media.tumblr.com/4d9ba18e9...09a5o4_250.gifhttp://38.media.tumblr.com/0f6b4f5ae...09a5o3_250.gif
http://31.media.tumblr.com/749ff736c...09a5o5_250.gifhttp://33.media.tumblr.com/8d7c5c1f8...09a5o7_250.gif

EVERYTHING about these scenes were just the best of the series and I cried like a baby.