kristi_adela

But, haven't you heard? Everyone knew he would eventually make detective because he was at the top of his class in Clone School. You can't deny that evidence. It's right there on his certificate.

scififan2009

I doubt he came from Kamino.

If the republic wanted more clone troopers, why not just use the same DNA from jango fett?

And the first order don't even use clones in the new trilogy. That explains Finn.

kristi_adela

It's canon that they can't fuse we saw that with Regina and the Evil Queen. They can share the darkness, but they can't remerge. We saw that in season 6. Technically, they can't be killed either because then the original would die. It just doesn't seem fair to create NotHook and give him no chance at a real future just to preserve one happy ending. And why not clone others as well? Why no Snow or Charming or Emma clones? is there something about the Charming family that prevents cloning?


The Empire quickly stopped using clones as well. That's why the Stromtroopers have slight variations in height and weight. I think they realized the clones were not that stable. Some of them rejected Order 66 and joined the Rebellion. It's all canon to the Once universe, because they are all technically part of the same Disneyverse. I doubt a bean could get them to Kamino and I think the clone facility was destroyed anyway. But, David was afraid of falling through a portal to Asgard, so anything is possible.

Radames

Only problem with your statement is that this Hook would not be created using the serum. He's not being separated into good and bad personas. The logic of the serum in S6 is thrown out the window with this scenario.

If call sheets are to be believed he's called "Wish Hook"(that's not what the characters will call him, just like WR Hook was not called "old hook" even though that is what was said in call sheets and scripts") which going by the name means he was created by a wish. From who, who knows however because of that potential scenario it can explain that he will either disappear once the mission is complete, he goes back to our Killian's body and fuses back with him, or he dies.

I think the remerging scenario would probably be best, as the timeline would have to correct itself.

Austenphile

Creating a wish Hook doesn't create an alternate timeline. If so, wish Robin would have created one.





Looks like the Charming's loft was recycled into Roni's.

Radames

It's okay if you guys have your doubts but the rules of the serum and S6 do not apply in this potential scenario.

Austenphile

I don't buy the clone theory. But even if I did, cloning someone doesn't create an alternate timeline unless you are implying the clone is going to time travel and change the past?

scififan2009

Now you're just pulling my leg.

Radames

Seems 7x05 is Tiana centric, hmm much like Aladdin was 6x05. Disney centric episode 5. We all know how Aladdin flopped despite big promotion for the episode. Aladdin is a much more popular property then Princess and the Frog, so not sure that's such a good thing.
It does create two timelines because two of the same person are walking around so that has to be corrected down the line.

kristi_adela

Here is a list of reason why a copy of Hook makes no sense

# 1 Just because you say so? That doesn't make it true.

#2 The characters have never just been able to wave their hands and create another person?

#3 That doesn't answer the question of why copy Hook? Why not Emma or Snow or Charming? Someone who is biologically related to Henry and Lucy? The logical answer is because those actors are never coming back. But, this theory is not based on logic. So, there has to be a reason why the Charming line can't be duplicated. What makes them special and unique? We have never had a copy of Emma, but Snowing appeared as copies
in the wish world. So, other versions of them exist. Why not copy one of them?

#4 From a storyline angle, Hook makes the least sense.

#5 If the copy is based on DNA, why does it have a missing hand? That is not a birth defect. The missing limb is not a part of Hook's DNA.

#6 So is it a photo copy? If so, how is it infused with a soul? If it has no soul, then why does it matter?

#7 If it is something physically split from Hook like the Evil Queen last season, is it a duality? If so, which is the Evil Hook?

#8 The writers would have to create a whole mythology for one character and they don't have time to do that. They have 10 characters to write for.

#9 Not to mention, they have repeatedly said their are no AU versions of Hook, Regina and Rumple. These are our versions of the characters. What you are suggesting is not out Hook, Regina and Rumple.

#10 Your only proof is a vague promise from Colin that Hook and Emma are Happy. I don't think that was a lie, but I don't think it represents the whole picture.

This is much more than I want to say on the subject.

scififan2009

Greenbacks title gave it away.

Austenphile

That's not two timelines. That's one timeline with 2 versions of the same person. Unless one of them time traveled.

Radames

yes but they both go on different paths so down the line it has to be put back onto one path. That is what I mean.

Yet some thought it was Tremaine centric.

Austenphile

I'll admit I thought of Lady Tremaine and dollars when I heard greenbacks. It's a more popular word for $ than frogs after all. But I don't care my theory was wrong. Now, I just hope the Prince Kevin Ryan is playing is not a white washed version of Naveen. That's taking the casting director's obvious "type" and hiring of almost identically looking dark haired men way too far.

Radames

Going from filming he's probably a shady prince alining with Tremaine and Drusilla. Not Naveen, I kind of think Naveen haas already been cast but it's being kept under wraps.

Or he's the prince charming for cinderella before Henry gets into the picture.

Yeah if they do Tiana's LI as a white guy I 100% expect a very big backlash as Naveen is a POC and a very important representation just like Tiana.