I agree with you. What does Logan have to gain by telling Lucy? He'll only be hurting Lucy, and maybe Marty. If he's taking a stab at Marty because of Rory, it seems vindictive and immature.

Psst. I just came back from the tour and according to the guide there has NOT been build a new set for Rory. Believe him or not. I take no responsibility if he was lying

That's true Jason, the truth is better than living a lie, even if it hurts, but I think Logan is not doing it for Lucy's sake, but for his own reasons.
It would have been better for Logan to confront Rory or Marty alone, to give them the chance to tell Lucy the truth on their own though.

We don't know that Logan hasn't talked about this with Rory. I'm pretty sure Rory told Logan about Marty acting weird, and Logan telling Rory to stop the charade and tell Lucy the truth or Marty to shove it. But Rory may have said "I can't just do that..." (Classic!)

Logan following along with the pretense (he would also have to pretend that HE didn't know Marty through Rory from before) would have made the lie stranger and bigger and bigger. I think he did it to expose Marty primarily, not to hurt Rory. Though I do think that Rory will be upset with him for what he did.

LL share a sweet moment... is it december 5th yet?

I agree with you. What does Logan have to gain by telling Lucy? He'll only be hurting Lucy, and maybe Marty. If he's taking a stab at Marty because of Rory, it seems vindictive and immature.

um, has this been brought over yet?

BuddyTV - Exclusive Interview: David S. Rosenthal, Head Writer and Executive Producer on Gilmore Girls

Thanks for the thread, Babs.

Peachy, we disagree about most subjects in relation to this show, and you have made it known how you feel about me. Should I not react to you as being wrong all the time? Should there be a different response? Luckily, I do not hold a grudge, and I did give you some dap in the last thread. Nevertheless, they are not unrecognizable shadows, and I will never stop fighting you or anyone else on this point. This is who they are. This is who they have always been. To me, you cannot blame the writers for seeing the characters in such a way, that you and many others never did. Remember: I am in this as well. Apparently, I was wrong, and watching the eps again...I see how wrong that I was to assume LL had some great ship. Luke and Lorelai are flawed people. I feel that many a JJ or LL fan, make them out to be SUPERHEROES (like charmed) how did I think she was a superhero?? , and glaze over all of their flaws, I never glazed over their flaws, I have yet to put one character on a pedastal like so many. When they are nothing but people with flaws. Trying to do the best they can. < I agree with that

Now on to charmed. Yay, I love being the center of attention Nice support of Lorelai. Essentially, again, you act as if you are Lorelai, and because you would do what Lorelai did. This makes Lorelai's actions A OK! Um, no, I think in terms of character behavior, she did the same thing when talking about Rory about Dean and loosing virginity thing. Lorelai went after her daughter when she walked out crying on the lawn, What was it Rory did?? Sit there and listen?? No, she didnt. Lorelai offered her an olive branch, Rory pushed her away. I was not basing my opinion on my experience, but what had happened in the past. Well, no, Lorelai's actions suck hairy wookie balls, and there is no defense for them. She sold out her kid. She did not have to blindingly support her kid. All Lorelai had to do was BE A MOM. IMO, she was being a mom, everyone thinks she should of just supported her daughters decision to leave college, I think if it was for something OTHER than Rory leaving cause Mitchum said she didnt have it, I think the situation would have been different, but She was leaving cause MH told her she didnt have it, she was knocked off her high horse, but the show has alwas portrayed Rory as confident in her ability as a journalism, she even took Paris down a notch at Chilton, again Im basing my opinion on past character behavior. Lorelai always supported her daughter, but I think it was very difficult for Lorelai not to help her daughter, but this was something that Rory had to figure out herself. Instead of being a mom. She decided to be a selfish brat, that got more mad about some pithy **** than her KID'S ISSUES. What's more important charmed? THE LOVE? OR THE BULL****? Lorelai chose the bull****. Not true, Lorelai tried tough love, she couldnt let Rory dwell in self pity, cause that was all it was, Lorelia knew her daughter, what she can do, she wanted her to know that MH wasnt the only one in the world who can see Rorys potential. All she had to do was be a MOM. She was being a mom, moms dont just say, okay you dropped out of school, sit home and sult till you get that door greeter at Walmart, She did what she had to do, take the cushion part out of Rory's life to make her stand on her own to figure out for herself who she is, thats beign a mom. That's different from being Rory's friend.

Finally, Chris is boring? Really? Why is he boring? Oh, he's not Luke. Sorry. I forgot that LUKE "BIG DICK JOHNSON" DANES is soooo deep and soooo interesting. My mistake. Yes, I am ****ing around, but this is the bizarro version take on all of your Chris is BORING discussion!

ETA: Panda, that's a ****ing post right there. You pretty much nailed. Lorelai is not a closer. She cannot close on the big situations in life. <true Hopefully, this will change, in the future.

And why is Logan involved in this pithy **** between Marty, Rory, and Lucy? You Marty lovin JJs will probably hate this, and the Sophies are most likely not down with it. However, Logan, so needs to drop Marty. <yup

Thanks for the new episode description. At least it gives us a little more to go by. I'm Very interested to see how LC fight over whether they should say their vows at this party turns out. Will they say it at the party or will it be the final nail in the coffin?

What about this is mature to begin with? By going along he would be perpetuation and growing an already immature lie. Marty is being ridiculous in the first place by pretending to not know her, which tells me there's more to the story there. He's told Lucy something about Rory that he doesn't want her to connect the dots and realize he's talking about her new friend. Rory's being dishonest and immature by facilitating and perpetuating the lie.

The real victim in all of this is Lucy.

We don't know what motivates him to tell Lucy, or if he discusses it with Rory or Marty, and we can speculate until the moon is blue, but we can't be sure of anything. My post was based on my own initial reaction to the way the episode description is worded. However it happens, I don't think it's Logan's place to tell Lucy anyway. As I said, what does he have to gain by doing that?