Spoilers - GG RL S&S Thread #271 - Who could say "no" to that sexy voice? - Page 3

fox24 · 05-01-2007, 07:33 PM

Proposing in front of other people is something people have done I even witnessed one a few years ago and she said yes so I don't see the problem. He just wanted to propose in front of all the people she loved

TheJSW · 05-01-2007, 07:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by catkirk7 (View Post)

Here's my thing about Logan proposing in front of everyone. Do I think it's out of character for him? Not necessarily. I think it's out of character to him to be proposing to Rory, a woman he knows very well, in front of everyone. He knows she's not the kind of girl to make a life-changing decision right away. He has to know that there's a chance she wouldn't say yes right away and would need a few pro/con lists. He KNOWS her. So why would he do this in front of everyone?

Because it's not about KNOWING HER. It's about declaring his love to her to her ENTIRE WORLD. It's a declaration. If she needs to make a ****ing list about a declaration of love. She's a piece of **** that deserves to grow old with cats. This proposal is the epitomy of romanticism. Too bad it's wasted on a waste of space like Rory LAMEASS Gilmore.

captnerin · 05-01-2007, 07:33 PM

also, lane and zack. another couple that rory should follow by example. i know this was mentioned before, about lane saying that thing about sacrifice. and another anvil if you could call it, rory questioned lane about the distance and time apart while he was going on tour. lane assured her that they were going to make it work.

so let's add it all up. the 2 paths in the maze, paris and doyle breaking up then getting back together because of the same circumstances that rory and logan will be approaching, and lane and zack. i'm still having a hard time believing that all this is going on and rory and logan remain broken up. maybe i'm in denial. maybe i'm being trying to find anything for some hope. but i still can't see logan being rejected by rory for marriage after all this. it's not that easy. for either of them. unless they've been lying about their love to each other. after the way that all of rory's past boyfriends have weaseled their ways back onto the show, i can't see 7.21 as the last time we'll see logan.

but then again, the writers are probably just heartless bastards and think that rory doesn't deserve a happy ending, full circle with love and success.

i tried to stay away until after MA. but i couldn't. i'll try again. let's cross our fingers that MA doesn't say anything that makes me want to toss my laptop across the room.

fox24 · 05-01-2007, 07:36 PM

By the way Zach did a public proposal again I don't see the problem

captnerin · 05-01-2007, 07:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheJSW (View Post)

Because it's not about KNOWING HER. It's about declaring his love to her to her ENTIRE WORLD. It's a declaration. If she needs to make a ****ing list about a declaration of love. She's a piece of **** that deserves to grow old with cats. This proposal is the epitomy of romanticism. Too bad it's wasted on a waste of space like Rory LAMEASS Gilmore.

true.

they're probably going to make rory look like she's unsure of herself, yet again. because the one time she didn't dwell on something for a week, she said no to the pro-jo, and look how that turned out. i'm tired of them showing her as such an undeceicive person. maybe it's just me. back from season 5.10, it looks like she still has logan's balls, but apparently hers are missing.

catkirk7 · 05-01-2007, 07:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheJSW (View Post)

Because it's not about KNOWING HER. It's about declaring his love to her to her ENTIRE WORLD. It's a declaration. If she needs to make a ****ing list about a declaration of love. She's a piece of **** that deserves to grow old with cats. This proposal is the epitomy of romanticism. Too bad it's wasted on a waste of space like Rory LAMEASS Gilmore.

I wouldn't be upset with her if she needed time to think through the timing. Clearly Logan is ok with her needing time. That's just who Rory is. Her saying no in such a way that it leads to a breakup because she needs her "independence" and "to be her own person" is what makes her suck.

gilmorebrazil · 05-01-2007, 07:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fox24 (View Post)

By the way Zach did a public proposal again I don't see the problem

True. And everyone in the scene was cheering for Lane to say yes.

rexsgirl29 · 05-01-2007, 07:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fox24 (View Post)

By the way Zach did a public proposal again I don't see the problem

and werent they even broken up at the time? or their relationship was in a bad place at that time? much worse then logan&rorys considering they arent even having problems

TheJSW · 05-01-2007, 08:08 PM

If you are 22 and as indecisive as Rory Gilmore. You really do not deserve anything in life because of your cowardice. She's a coward. Who, at some point, is going to have grow a pair of ovaries, and stop acting like everything needs a weeks worth of debate. Sometimes you either go for it or you dont. You dont wait a week to decide if you want to marry a person unless you are a grandiose *******. I state as much with equivocation.

So, Rory, is an *******, and Logan is being screwed over due to her *******ry. Yay. What a great way for this season to end. I am overjoyed. Nevertheless, I do not think Logan is happy with giving her time, and I am hope they keep the takes of Logan yelling at Rory. Since that coward needs to be yelled at in a real big way.

ETA: The only thing we can take from Lane and Zachk and Paris and Doyle in comparion to Rory and Logan is this...Rory obviously is not as mature as either of her friends. She's an immature whose not ready for anything more than

from mommy's

and working for an online mag.

SabLuvsLogan · 05-01-2007, 08:14 PM

I found the new promo on youtube
YouTube - GG Promo 7.21

catkirk7 · 05-01-2007, 08:39 PM

I'm wondering if we'll actually see what Lorelai says to Logan. If the episode will pick up right after this one ended.

SabLuvsLogan · 05-01-2007, 08:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by catkirk7 (View Post)

I'm wondering if we'll actually see what Lorelai says to Logan. If the episode will pick up right after this one ended.

I hope so because we get riped off enough by DR. We need to see that scene play out.

TheJSW · 05-01-2007, 08:55 PM

I dont really need to see Lorelai going "HUMINNA HUMINNNA HUMINNNNNA!" She obviously does not want her daughter to leave. Rosenthal is obviously sending Logan to the other end of the country for a reason. So Rory can be on the east coast, with her mommy, and her lame ass friend. Again...squeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.

La Linn · 05-01-2007, 09:05 PM

Wow only two scenes, MC sure gets a lot of screen time this year lol. No wonder he doesnt' want to come back/it's obvious Dr doesn't want him back next year.

Rory looks afraid when Logan proposes.

So only one more episode of GG left. It's a strange felling.

catkirk7 · 05-01-2007, 09:06 PM

The closest thing to "scoop" from Ausiello (other than LL kiss is "relatively long")

Quote:

Question: This whole waiting for an official announcement about the fate of Gilmore Girls is giving me an anxiety disorder. Any new developments?— Michelle A.
Ausiello: Not a one.