wolkenfuehlen

Aww, you can't blame Finn for wanting to see what was going on, can you? Though I agree, he could've just waited a tiny bit longer, until Jake was in the showers.

Mrs. Somerhalder

Oh yeah, I can't blame him for that.
But his timing was sooo wrong!

Veronakat

yeah, I bet Finn was dying to know what was going on in the showers since Jake and Ham wasn't in the pillow war. But he could just look from outside in silence instead of walking straight into them.
Do you think he figure out about Jake or that he didn't see anyting?

Mrs. Somerhalder

I'm betting he was still clueless.

wolkenfuehlen

I think he definitely did. Even if he only saw her for a couple of seconds, he must've seen something.

Veronakat

So if we had a second season of YA, you'd like that Finn would have noticed Jake was girl and keep the secret or that he thought that Hamilton was gay and just a warned to be carfetul with their relationship?

wolkenfuehlen

You know, I really don't know. Both seem possible to me, and both have been done quite well in fanfic. I guess we'll never know how they really would've wanted to continue the show... *sigh*

Veronakat

You're right Anja, I thing both are possible and would work fine with the story.

I'd particularly like better if Finn thought Jake was a boy. It'd be very interesting to see how they'd manage to have an 'apparently' gay relationship in New Rawley. I know all the guys already had their suspictions but if Finn would find out would be like more real. And what would the Dean and Kate say to Hamilton?
I think I should reread New Beginnings and Nicky's fics again to find out

wolkenfuehlen

You're right, it would be a very interesting twist to their story. Not just everyone else's reactions, but also how Ham and Jake would deal with 'really' being a gay couple.

Yes you should! And I should to! If only I had the time... *sigh*

Veronakat

Tell me about it. And now we even have fics from Nelle's site to reread
See? If Jake is showing her back to Finn and he's half cover with those feathers, he probably wasn't sure what he was looking at




Pictures from Vertigo site

Mrs. Somerhalder

Yup, it isn't obvious at all. But Jake freaked out, and maybe that had Finn thinking?

Naughty Hamilton... taking a peek.

Veronakat

Yes, I think that definitely had Finn thinking but probably that they were both gay instead that Jake had breasts?

Mrs. Somerhalder

Yes, possibly.

B.Chambers

Add me?

Schumiac

Finally watched this and I am CRAZY about him now!

Hamilton is ! The shower scene was pretty hot just based on the "idea" of it. It is weird. I think it is just how they were acting, they totally sold it, which proves with the right actors a scene that doesn't really show sex or making out or anything can still be über-hot. Ian was a big reason why it was so hot though. Him making sexy "grrrr" noices is


Hamilton is like the best boyfriend ever. Nevermind the looks, his personality owns! He is so understanding and easy-going and loves so deeply and will face anything for it! So adorable!

Add me to the list, oh yeah, definitely!