 |
| ||||||||||||||||||
|
|  |
|  | |
|
|  |
|  | | ||||||
 |  | |||||||||
|
| #31 | |||
| Loyal Fan   Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,331
| im really happy but not as well at the same time. I hated the way Doctor one didnt seem to care that much about leaving Rose..im just not sure what to think. Watching confidential made me feel better about it, but .... i need some time to process it __________________ Emma  Lucas ♥ Haley "I could never officially give you away, you know that. I could never give away my best friend" Icon:??? | |||
|
| #32 | |||
| Dedicated Fan  Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 760
| So many emotions going on in my head right now not sure what i feel But the doctor could never be with rose cause Doctor who doesnt work like that he isnit allowed romance __________________ Linda Avi from davidtennant.com | |||
|
|
| #33 | |||
| Loyal Fan  Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,306
| I was too mad to even bother watching Confidential. Like I said, I just felt really cheated by that ending. To me, they both can't be The Doctor. And *shakes head*, I just don't feel they did The Doctor and Rose justice. It seemed like the easy way out for a happy ending and it just really wasn't. __________________ "And I will walk on water, And you will catch me if I fall" ~ J. Wade Icon: mikeyrhcp | |||
|
|
| #34 | |||
| Extreme Fan  Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 2,136
| Quote:
I obviously know people won't agree with me but it's just the way I feel. I am glad Rose got a Doctor but it just wasn't HER Doctor, in my eyes!!!! I still loved the episode. I'm not bad mouthing it or anything just what I feel!!! __________________ "I suddenly got obsessive about boxing and Muhammad Ali around the time he was fighting Joe Frazier. I went off and did boxing. I looked incredibly good in the gym." Gary Oldman | |||
|
|
| #35 | |||
| Total Fan  Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 7,983
| The are the same though, you know like Nine and Ten are different but still the same man. __________________ Siobhan | |||
|
|
| #36 | |||
| Part-Time Fan  Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 398
| Quote:
If one goes by your logic then Ten is not the same as the Ninth Doctor, which we know is not the case, they are the same. Just as Doctor no. 2 is Doctor no. 1. He's made out of him afterall. __________________ Rebecca Doctor&Rose | Chuck&Blair | |||
|
|
| #37 | |||
| Extreme Fan Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 2,136
| Quote:
Nine/Ten. Both two hearts, both time lords.....same person. Doctor 2....he was a clone..... This is driving me mad haha!!! Maybe we should agree to disagree!! My mind is crazy!! __________________ "I suddenly got obsessive about boxing and Muhammad Ali around the time he was fighting Joe Frazier. I went off and did boxing. I looked incredibly good in the gym." Gary Oldman | |||
|
|
| #38 | |||
| Passionate Fan  Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 3,522
| Quote:
 But why does every series have to end with him abandoning her on that beach, it wasn't easy the first time and I'm not getting any more used to it!  __________________ "these people are my friends and my family, icon | |||
|
|
| #39 | |||
| Dedicated Fan Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 760
| even though rose snogged the other doctor the way she looked at the tardis as he left oh god going to cry again. She got what she always wanted but then she didnt. Hopefully the doctor wont be sad for too long he did give her him kinda of Confusing thanks RTD __________________ Linda Avi from davidtennant.com | |||
|
|
| #40 | |||
| Total Fan Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 7,983
| Yeah let's just agree to disagree. A clone is Martha in The Poison Sky, this is a botched regeneration, they have the same face the same memories. everything. I'll shut up now. Is it bad that the first thing I though was "poor Rose she has the dreaded blue suit"  __________________ Siobhan | |||
|
|
| #41 | |||
| Extreme Fan Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 2,136
| I'm going to move on now......My head hurts!!! "He needs you....that's very me!" "I've only got one life Rose Tyler, I can spend it with you" "Does it need saying?" YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Please don't whisper it.....haha __________________ "I suddenly got obsessive about boxing and Muhammad Ali around the time he was fighting Joe Frazier. I went off and did boxing. I looked incredibly good in the gym." Gary Oldman | |||
|
|
| #42 | |||
| Loyal Fan Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,306
| Quote:
I completely, and wholeheartedly agree with you. I know what you mean. It wasn't her doctor. I don't think you can make the nine/ten comparison. For one, he has only one heart, and like I said before The Doctor she fell in love with had the burden of outliving everyone around him and everyone he loves. That is a strong emotion that's an innate part of The Doctor - not one the duplicate Doctor can possibly feel or understand. Therfore, he is different. He is NOT the same man Rose loves. That's just how I see it. They can't possibly be the same and the one. __________________ "And I will walk on water, And you will catch me if I fall" ~ J. Wade Icon: mikeyrhcp | |||
|
|
| #43 | |||
| Dedicated Fan Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 760
| Maybe rose was fed up being alone and the other doctor told her what she wanted to hear. She knew she would never get the real doctor so she grab at a chance of possibly happiness. hope that makes sense __________________ Linda Avi from davidtennant.com | |||
|
|
| #44 | |||
| Passionate Fan  Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 3,304
| I really dont know what to think about that ending...it was probably the happiest ending Doctor and Rose could have got given the circumstances, and obviously i was happy to see a full on snog finally between the two (did you guys see the confidential? Billie and David were proper going for it! ) But...I hated the way the proper doctor didnt even really say goodbye and the ending with him alone in the tardis was quite possible the most depressing thing i've ever seen. Why cant he ever have one minute of happiness bless him!! __________________ CT: ...and thats the tragedy of Donna Noble, that she'll probably never reach any potential, because she doesnt know she's got any. But hopefully she'll be happy....sky plus-ing x factor.... | |||
|
|
| #45 | |||
| Part-Time Fan Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 398
| I think it was a nice gift to Rose, she could grow old with the Doctor, the modified version!  The fact is that the real Doctor knew he could never be with her in the way she wanted, and he would lose her again one day. It was a big sacrifice on his part to give her as close to a happy ending as he could.__________________ Rebecca Doctor&Rose | Chuck&Blair | |||
|
|
  |
| Thread Tools | |||||||
| |||||||
| |
