[CommanderM]

Originally Posted by Summer Falls (View Post) True i feel she did die but im not sure

I liked this two-parter. Clara looked so good in it. Even when Jenna was playing a baddie. The Doctor in his Tardis playing the guitar again, how grand that was!
All in all, it felt like Dr. Who.

[Almeida's Army]

Originally Posted by CommanderM (View Post) I liked this two-parter. Clara looked so good in it. Even when Jenna was playing a baddie. The Doctor in his Tardis playing the guitar again, how grand that was! All in all, it felt like Dr. Who.

Yeah for me it was by a clear country mile the best of what was otherwise a pretty dire series. They were definitely the standouts. Even so, it still doesn't come close to the classic classic whos, but it may get on a par with stuff like Mawdryn Undead or The Happiness Patrol or Claws of Axos etc- good, watchable Who but not on a par with the Genesis of the Daleks, Talons of Weng-Chiang or City of Death of the Whoniverse imo.

[CommanderM]

Originally Posted by Almeida's Army (View Post) Yeah for me it was by a clear country mile the best of what was otherwise a pretty dire series. They were definitely the standouts. Even so, it still doesn't come close to the classic classic whos, but it may get on a par with stuff like Mawdryn Undead or The Happiness Patrol or Claws of Axos etc- good, watchable Who but not on a par with the Genesis of the Daleks, Talons of Weng-Chiang or City of Death of the Whoniverse imo.

I think it was pretty much like standard Who fare like The Claws of Axos so no argument from me on that score.

[Almeida's Army]

Originally Posted by CommanderM (View Post) I think it was pretty much like standard Who fare like The Claws of Axos so no argument from me on that score.

Agreed. It was good, standard, watchable Who. Nothing on the Genesis level but equally miles and miles ahead of the dross we've had to endure these past few years.

[CommanderM]

Originally Posted by Almeida's Army (View Post) Agreed. It was good, standard, watchable Who. Nothing on the Genesis level but equally miles and miles ahead of the dross we've had to endure these past few years.

Again, we are in total agreement where it counts.

[One Thing Remains]

The cliffhanger regarding Clara in this episode was amazing

[Summer Falls]

Originally Posted by One Thing Remains (View Post) The cliffhanger regarding Clara in this episode was amazing

yes these episodes were fantastic

[One Thing Remains]

I really enjoyed them too