dancing in the rain

Cereal Killer

I just hope Janelle will outlast Amber.

dancing in the rain

I think in general she is more likeable but the judges keep making Amber look much better than she is and kind of give an OK to Janelle. I guess we'll have to see tonight.

sarah598

The judges continued with their praising of Amber telling us to vote for her. It will be interesting to see if that backfires on them.
I really liked Angie, Candice and Kree's second performances Candice did a pretty cool version of Straight Up, as did Kree with She Talks to Angels and Angie with I'll Stand by You. I'll Stand by You is kinda Pia's Idol song for me though
Mariah and Nicki actually spoke to each other

BlackWhiteRose

OMG Angie was so great last night! Her second performance just knocked my socks off!
And Candice what should I say? I love her! Especially the second performance!
Janelle made me dance to her second performance. Really groovy!
Her first was beautiful too! (Janelle)
Amber was beautiful too! Booth perfomances! But the second one was a little better.
Kree was very good as always. I was so relieved she didn`t sing "My heart will go on" (´cause I don`t like that song and I think its an anoying song and I`m not a Celine Dion fan at all sorry)
Damn its so hard to choose but my top four are:

Angie, Candice, Kree and Amber. And my top three are still Candice, Angie and Kree.

BTW: the babypictures of the girls were so cute! Awww


And I lauged about Ryan (the host) when he keept talking faster and faster after one performance (can`t remember which one)*LOL*

topherkraz78

He could totally be an auctioneer. Tune in tonight! Clay Aiken returns after 7 years! WOW!

BlackWhiteRose

Now I rewatched it and it was after Ambers first performance when Ryan did this fast talking thing. I loved it he should do this more often
I don`t know if an auctioneer is talking so fast

sarah598

^That was funny when Ryan did that

Clay's performance was really good! Liked Fantasia's too, so much emotion from her.

I'm confused, I didn't know the save was still in play yet tonight. I would rather have seen Amber go home than Janelle. I'm so sad Kree was in the bottom 2 with Janelle

topherkraz78

So how long is this damn save good for?

Cereal Killer

Janelle.

So I guess the rules have been made to be broken. I didn't know the save was still available either and frankly, I really don't know why they didn't use it. They might have as well at this point. Does it mean they can STILL use it next week? Obviously they want a specific top 3 or something but I don't think that's a surprise...

sarah598

Sorry about Janelle, I know she was your favorite And you're right, they might as well have used the save on her at this point. Now I really have no idea long they are able to use it.

topherkraz78

So is the finale May 9th?

MrღMrsStinsbatskys

Candice is my Queen, she's an angel that voice is stunning. Love her!

I never felt Kree as a performer I never payed much attention to her so my opinion on her is NONE. However, I really thought she would've got the save if she did go home.

NikNak

dancing in the rain

Thanks for posting that Nikki. It seems they're keeping it around as much as possible in case one of their picks get eliminated before the finals but at this point, I don't get why, they got their wish of a girl winning, are they pushing for someone in particular?

Laura, sorry about Janelle I seriously still don't get the unbelievable praise for Amber. Mariah said something along the lines of "If there was something above/beyond first place" .. Really? And the standing-O for the first performance .. even Randy kind of took it back and said it wasn't really perfect but more because she tackled that song..

I haven't seen the whole episode yet, just bits and pieces. Angie killed on both performances and her dedication to Boston was really sweet. I really liked the way she did Halo, enjoyed it quite a bit.