American Idol & Idol Shows - 7- 22: "Top 11 Performances" 03.18.2008 Discussion

howmuchforhappy · 03-18-2008, 02:23 PM

The Top 11 American Idol contestants perform at 8/7 central tonight. The theme is still songs from the Lennon-McCartney collection.

howmuchforhappy · 03-18-2008, 05:38 PM

Michael is seriously making me so hot. Who knew a Beatles song could do that? But this is probably my favorite performance of his.

Kristy... blah. I don't even know why I bother with her anymore.

David A definitely stepped it up this week, but I just didn't like it. It was really bland.

Amanda should be out like ASAP.

Brunette-beats-all-sucka · 03-18-2008, 05:48 PM

Amanda- she is getting pretty boring. Every week she just yells and rocks and yells and yeah... boring.

Kristy- I like her personality..too bad she sucks at singing.

David A- A million times better than last week!! I thought he sang that song beautifully!!! Go David!!

Michael- A good song for him, but I still haven't been wowed by him since Bohemian Rhapsody. Hopefully he will find a way to kick ass soon enough.

**ROCKSTAR** · 03-18-2008, 05:52 PM

Didn't like Brooke a whole lot and she talks too much.

Wasn't feeling Michael either.

abw92 · 03-18-2008, 05:54 PM

I thought Brooke's performance was her weakest. She is talking too much.

Michael is hot and I love his accent, but I didn't like it. It was alright, but a few notes were off.

I love David. I'll admit, I was giggling during his whole interview.

Usually, I don't like guys like him, but he drew me in.

Kristy should've left instead of David. Her performance sucked and David would've been better.

Amanda's was nothing new. I also couldn't understand parts of what she was saying.

rummagingforanswers · 03-18-2008, 06:03 PM

Quote:

David A definitely stepped it up this week, but I just didn't like it. It was really bland.

Sameeee.

He does have a good voice, but I just don't enjoy his style.

-res cogitans- · 03-18-2008, 06:14 PM

Simon is really annoying me. I really dont like him at all anymore. Doesn't know what he's talking about tonight. Not that any of the judges ever do.

Amanda was awesome, rocked it, A bit shaky in the beginning but so what

Kristy. A bit of a mess. Ended on a good note though. She should go home this week tho

David A. Boring as hell. Put me to sleep. Vocals weren't great either.

Michael wasnt great. It was alright...not a good song choice. Disappointing after last week

Brooke was not good this week..and i love her. and the song.

David C was great vocally and performance wise as usual but not as exciting as other weeks. Not my fav of his because his others have been so outstanding. Didnt like the song

Carly was just not good.

Jason singing in french was sexy but i hate that song. It was alright. He's still adorable but im worrying about his song choices of late.

Syesha- did not like it. Hated the way she sung it...way too much. Vocals didnt impress me. No emotion

not a good week this week...sad because last week was pretty damn good

Ramiele- vocals were alright. didnt like it though. awful song

bad night

No more beatles ever please!

**ROCKSTAR** · 03-18-2008, 06:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Insanitic (View Post)

not a good week this week...sad because last week was pretty damn good

The energy level wasn't great. I guess they're getting tired, which is normal.

howmuchforhappy · 03-18-2008, 06:59 PM

I know. I really think they made a huge mistake doing Beatles 2 weeks ina row.

David Cook, you are proving just what I've been saying this whole time. Taking classics and trying to Daughtry-fy them. Not cool. I just don't get him at all.

Syesha, what was that? I just didn't get it.

I love Jason. Not the best choice of song, but he's too adorable to hate.

Chikezie picked probably my favorite of the songs. I thought he did pretty good, and I'm not a fan of him.

Ramiele. I don't know what to do with her. She's awesome, but the song choices just aren't working out.

-res cogitans- · 03-18-2008, 07:05 PM

No more beatles ever please!

Im sure we can all agree on this

.:DoDs:. · 03-18-2008, 08:20 PM

Wow i didn't like anyone!!!

That's scary!
Carly was the best, but still.. eh

Next week theme needs to be itunes top100 and Brooke has to sing Love Song!!

rose parade · 03-18-2008, 08:20 PM

This week sucked, end of story. The best was Carly and that wasn't even that good. Jason is great though, as is Ramiele.

rainydays · 03-18-2008, 08:43 PM

I'm on the west coast and have only seen the first four performers. I am probably going to miss a lot because of OTH.

Anyway, it has been pretty boring so far. So far, I thought everyone was okay but not great. David A. was good but I don't think "amazing". Where did Simon come up with that? I don't think he has every gotten as good as he was during Imagine....

Kristy and Michael were blah.

**ROCKSTAR** · 03-18-2008, 09:01 PM

The Beatles two weeks in a row is odd. Beatle songs are really difficult to pull off because they looks so easy to play/sing. They're simple songs but when you try to over sing them they sound terrible. That happened a lot tonight.

Let It Be is probably one of the easiest if you have a nice range. I'm not surprised that Brooke was praised for that one last week.

cutiepie33 · 03-18-2008, 09:43 PM

Wow, I was not impressed by anyone tonight. I was bored pretty much the entire show and was watching the clock to see when it would be over. Definitely wish that I would have watched OTH or BB(even though I got them both taped anyway, but still...).

I like Carly, but I wasn't blown away. Amanda just needs to stop yelling. She's starting to hurt my ears. David A. was kinda boring. I don't get the whole fascination with him. David Cook seemed really cocky, like Simon said. He was trying to be too much like Chris Daughtry. I've got news for ya, buddy, you're no Daughtry. Sorry. Syesha was pretty good, but it was so boring. Kristy should have gone last week. I just didn't get Brooke's. Jason was actually kinda good, but it just seemed weird. I friggin love Michael, but the arrangement was just very, very awkward.

I agree whole-heartedly. NO MORE BEATLES EVER!!!!!!!!!!!