[LMS]

Originally Posted by Callalily They were perfection tonight and I am in such a dilema because I have been a Andy/Nina shipper from the beginning but I love Jake so much!

I used to be an Andy/Nina in the beginning, but now for me that ship has sunken. I just feel that their relationship is one-sided. IT is clear that Andy (and his children) need Nina. But I don't think Nina needs Andy at all. At this point, I would find it hard to believe that Nina would choose Andy over Jake.

[xxlisaxx]

I love them so much, but I have a bad feeling things aren't going to go well for them. I hope I'm wrong. Personally, I haven't wanted Nina/Andy since season one. I don't think he's good enough and I'm afraid he'll take advantage of her more than he already does.

Lisa

[thegreenlight]

Holy crap, I loved Jake/Nina last night. Their scenes were awesome.

[Callalily]

I feel so bad for Jake now. Even though I still love him and Nina I want Andy/Nina.

[thegreenlight]

Ah, man. This thread was waaayy far back.

Anyway, yay(!), Nina picked Jake!! They're so cute.

[Forwood4Bamon]

I would like to be added. I loved these two. I love Scott Wolf and I think he's adorable on Everwood and Party of Five.

[everwoodfan52]

Originally Posted by loganandroryforever (View Post) I would like to be added. I loved these two. I love Scott Wolf and I think he's adorable on Everwood and Party of Five.

Rachel, I'd love to add you, but there is no shippers list in the Opening post.

[Forwood4Bamon]

Originally Posted by everwoodfan52 (View Post) Rachel, I'd love to add you, but there is no shippers list in the Opening post.

oh yea I noticed that.

['Tos]

What did you think about how the relationship ended, Rachel? With Jake leaving, realizing that Nina wanted to be with Andy? Did you feel like that was a good ending?

[Forwood4Bamon]

Originally Posted by 'Tos (View Post) What did you think about how the relationship ended, Rachel? With Jake leaving, realizing that Nina wanted to be with Andy? Did you feel like that was a good ending?

Well Grant I teared up a lot when they were together. They went through a lot together. I did tear up. I may be in the minority on liking them as a couple. I think it was a good ending, I felt bad for Jake though. I thought he was a great guy.

[everwoodfan52]

Originally Posted by loganandroryforever (View Post) Well Grant I teared up a lot when they were together. They went through a lot together. I did tear up. I may be in the minority on liking them as a couple. I think it was a good ending, I felt bad for Jake though. I thought he was a great guy.

Yes, I agree..Jake was a great guy. I felt badly for him as well. He did the right thing. He realized that Nina did not love him as much as she loved Andy. I am happy, though, that Nina was free to go back to Andy.

['Tos]

Do you (the royal you, heh) think that if Nina went to California with Jake, that she would have eventually gotten out of the relationship, or would she have waited for him to break it up, hoping he would realize that she loved Andy?

[Forwood4Bamon]

Originally Posted by 'Tos (View Post) Do you (the royal you, heh) think that if Nina went to California with Jake, that she would have eventually gotten out of the relationship, or would she have waited for him to break it up, hoping he would realize that she loved Andy?

hmm that's a tough question. are you directing the question at me Grant?

['Tos]

Originally Posted by loganandroryforever (View Post) hmm that's a tough question. are you directing the question at me Grant?

To anyone. But, hey, at least you responded.

It is a tough one, though, for sure. It just seemed like Nina was reluctant to get out of the relationship with Jake, even though she clearly loved Andy. She was willing to move to a whole other town, a whole other state, even though she was moving with a man she didn't love as much as Andy. I wonder how long she would have been willing to do that, if even forever if need be.

[Forwood4Bamon]

Originally Posted by 'Tos (View Post) To anyone. But, hey, at least you responded. It is a tough one, though, for sure. It just seemed like Nina was reluctant to get out of the relationship with Jake, even though she clearly loved Andy. She was willing to move to a whole other town, a whole other state, even though she was moving with a man she didn't love as much as Andy. I wonder how long she would have been willing to do that, if even forever if need be.

Yeah. I don't know. I'm not the biggest Andy/Nina fan.