break the window

agreed. However, for them to just ambush Andy and the kids like that and demand all the things they did was quite unreasonable.

For Colin's parents to have him hooked up to machines for so long was a bit far fetched.

everwoodfan52

I disagree. He was their son and they still had hope.


Colin's mom should not have thrown Amy out of his hospital.

'Tos

Hmm, disagree, but only barely. I don't think she went about it in the right way, but I don't think she was wrong either about how Amy was putting pressure and setting up expectations. I think she should have talked to Harold first, though, and had Harold talk to Amy.

Jake deserved someone fantastic, even if it wasn't Nina.

break the window

agreed. Jake deserved someone who would see past the exterior that he built up for other people. The girl that would be ready to take on his life full of everything from LA and be okay with that. Jake's biggest thing in Everwood was acceptance. He just wanted to be apart of something.

Amanda/Andy affair would've have happened if John was just away on business all the time.

'Tos

Disagree in a big way. I think Andy was only able to justify it to himself because John was essentially comatose.

It's too bad that Linda didn't stick around so that we could have done without Amanda.

LemonyPie

Definitely agreed. Linda is a thousand times better than Amanda. Not even comparable.

Madison/Ephram started out okay but got worse and worse as it went on.

break the window

agree. It was like Ephram had to do things to keep up with Madison's life.

if Ephram had met his son it would've been harder for him to forgive Andy

'Tos

Hmm, I actually think it would be the opposite. I think he would have realized sooner--as he did in S4--what Andy was trying to do.

Ephram meeting his son in S5 would have been too early for Ephram.

everwoodfan52

I agree. It would have been much better to meet his son when his son was older. I would have loved to hear their conversation.

Delia lost some of her adorableness season 4.

LemonyPie

Agreed. I think she lost a lot of her adorableness as soon as season 2 though.

Tommy was not a bad-intentioned guy.

'Tos

I agree for the most part, although his attitude to Amy in his final scene makes me question that just a little. But I think he would regret those words and regret not having a friend like Amy.

Julia never would have allowed Delia to have a friend like Brittany.

LemonyPie

Disagreed. I think Julia would talk to Delia about it a lot and would advise against having Brittany as a friend and explain why she feels that way, but I don't think she would do anything like absolutely forbid Delia to see her anymore or anything like that.

It's a little sketchy that Rose only realized she loved Harold after realizing that he loved her.

'Tos

Agreed. I think she was in the situation where Harold loved her more than she loved him initially, but I think that changed and they were equally in love over time.

Jake knew all along that he loved Nina more than she loved him back.

LemonyPie

Agreed. I think he knew that her feelings for Andy were still present, and that something between them wasn't quite perfect.

Even though Colin told Amy that he loved her the day before he died, he probably didn't love her romantically and was instead just thankful for all she did for him.

break the window

agreed. Colin was just blown away at how much Amy took care of him, but he could never fall in love with her because he was never in love with her to begin with.

If Madison had a miscarriage, Andy would feel off the hook and never tell Ephram