Dawson's Creek - Dumbo Lovers {Pacey/Andie} #103: Because she chose him and will always choose him. - Page 4

**JJH85** · 05-23-2016, 07:43 PM

I could easily see Pacey and Andie rekindling their relationship in the finale. I would have liked to have seen a couple more scenes than what we got with the ones that were cut.

cyndie57 · 05-23-2016, 11:43 PM

I know right ?

if only

Quote:

Originally Posted by WileyDairyGnome (View Post)

Miss these guys.

Chris

so great to see you here

Any chance you are going to update your awesome fic Feels Like Home To Me ?

**JJH85** · 05-24-2016, 08:43 PM

cyndie57 · 05-25-2016, 01:17 AM

Love this scene so much

and also Sarah McLachlan song

Mirabell · 05-26-2016, 11:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Speedychatterbox (View Post)

In my opinion, Pacey did not need Joey to be happy. Unless one is a diehard PJ fan, Pacey being written and portrayed in the series finale to be completely over Joey and happy enjoying the single life or being in a committed loving relationship with a woman he adores and adores him back would not have been unbelievable.

That wouldn't have been unbelievable at all. I mean, it's five years!
Problem is, the script tells us otherwise. Believable or not, Pacey was not over Joey during this five years (and she wasn't either), and that makes a reunion in the finale with Andie quite difficult. How would you explain the audience (and the audience had a majority of Pacey/Joey-Fans or at least diehard Pacey-Fans like me), that his feelings changed all of sudden? Maybe it's not impossible, but you would have need more than this scene with Andie (although I LOVE this scene!) to make it believable .

Quote:

Originally Posted by Speedychatterbox (View Post)

A pandie romance ending is only unbelievable to some because Andie was written out in s4 for pretty much the duration of the show, and in s3 pandie had little interaction. If Andie remain on the show in s4 and for the show's duration, and the fans got to see pandie rebuilt back up then a pandie ending would not be so unbelievable. Pacey was written to be over Andie, so most fans would need to see Pacey falling for Andie all over again and being written to be certain that she was the one for him. Andie is a wonderful woman and I could easily buy Pacey falling for her after spending loads of time with her.

That is, in my opinion, absolutely true. My sentiments exactly!
And by the way, I would have loved to see them rebuild their fantastic relationship like this.

Quote:

Anyway for me the show ended season four when Andie came back from Italy and Pacey told her how much she meant to him and that he would have not made it with out her.(not the exact words), and Dawson and Joey were snogging in Dawson's bedroom.

It's not really my ending, because Pacey is too sad and too destroyed after season 4 to accept this as an ending, he needs to prove he is not just a failure first, but I really love these scenes when Andie came back in season 4.

It was so nice to see a happy Pacey after all the drama. After the promicide-nightmare it was lovely to see how uncomplicated it is between Pacey and Andie. And I'm always melting when they hug the first time.

During my season-2-rewatch, I realize again, how much I love this couple. I like Joey/Pacey as well, they had their moments, but Pacey/Andie is very special. I watched the scene today when Andie confesses to Dawson that she likes Pacey. That was the scene where she conquered my heart, she was just so adorable!

pandiexjeyton · 05-26-2016, 05:54 PM

ugh I miss these two. I loved both characters when they were together.

TL22 · 05-26-2016, 07:02 PM

Quote:

That wouldn't have been unbelievable at all. I mean, it's five years!
Problem is, the script tells us otherwise. Believable or not, Pacey was not over Joey during this five years (and she wasn't either), and that makes a reunion in the finale with Andie quite difficult. How would you explain the audience (and the audience had a majority of Pacey/Joey-Fans or at least diehard Pacey-Fans like me), that his feelings changed all of sudden? Maybe it's not impossible, but you would have need more than this scene with Andie (although I LOVE this scene!) to make it believable

.

When Kevin Williamson accepted writing the last two episodes Metedith Monroe was one of the first people he called. Meredith was filming something else and could not give Kevin the two or three weeks he wanted her for. She managed to squeeze out one day.

I wonder what would have happened if she was able to be there for the full two or three weeks

**JJH85** · 05-28-2016, 10:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TL22 (View Post)

.

When Kevin Williamson accepted writing the last two episodes Metedith Monroe was one of the first people he called. Meredith was filming something else and could not give Kevin the two or three weeks he wanted her for. She managed to squeeze out one day.

I wonder what would have happened if she was able to be there for the full two or three weeks

We could envision that "married woman" didn't exist and that Pacey travelled to Boston on a regular basis to see Andie and that she came down to Capeside when she wasn't working double shifts. Afterall Boston was only about an hour away. I travelled every day for an hour just to get to work in my old job, so that is believable.

OutoftheWoods · 05-29-2016, 06:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cyndie57 (View Post)

I know right ?

if only

Chris

so great to see you here

Any chance you are going to update your awesome fic Feels Like Home To Me ?

Aww.

You've always loved my fic. You know what, maybe I will update it sometime soon.

I feel like I need to start rewatching the show again soon and get back into a bit of a Creek Craze to get myself into continuing the fic.

cyndie57 · 05-30-2016, 12:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WileyDairyGnome (View Post)

Aww.

You've always loved my fic. You know what, maybe I will update it sometime soon.

I feel like I need to start rewatching the show again soon and get back into a bit of a Creek Craze to get myself into continuing the fic.

I totally understand and I'm so happy that there's still a possibility for you to update

**Liability** · 06-01-2016, 12:25 AM

I haven't posted here in such a long time! Pacey/Andie remain one of my favorite things about DC and definitely one of my favorite ships ever. And so many memories seeing the OP I put together still up there! I love these two.

**JJH85** · 06-06-2016, 12:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chastainღ (View Post)

I haven't posted here in such a long time! Pacey/Andie remain one of my favorite things about DC and definitely one of my favorite ships ever. And so many memories seeing the OP I put together still up there! I love these two.

Welcome back to the Board. You are going to have to do another re-watch to keep the DC Love alive.

Some of the OPs from way back were so good we hate to change them, so thanks for your contribution to those.

pandiexjeyton · 06-07-2016, 06:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chastainღ (View Post)

I haven't posted here in such a long time! Pacey/Andie remain one of my favorite things about DC and definitely one of my favorite ships ever. And so many memories seeing the OP I put together still up there! I love these two.

Welcome back

**JJH85** · 06-15-2016, 09:36 PM

OMG how adorable is this pic?

pandiexjeyton · 06-16-2016, 11:42 AM

I always wondered if that was a promo shot.

Forum Affiliates
Joshua Jackson Network - Your source for Josh!, Jensen Ackles Portugal, Dawsons Creeks Gifs, Pacey & Joey Daily, Michelle Williams Daily
Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page


Fan Forum > TV Shows - Past > Dawson's Creek > Dumbo Lovers {Pacey/Andie} #103: Because she chose him and will always choose him.