loulalla

Hey everyone i just thought I'd open a thread for a bit of a game. Every few days or whenever we can ask for a top 5 of something DC concerning and then everyone can post their personal top 5. I just thought it would be fun and interesting....

(kelly and emily if this isnt allowed, please delete it )

So to start us off the first Top 5 is for Worst episodes.

Top 5 worst episodes of Dawsons Creek
1.Downtown Crossing (like Dr Phil says "what were you thinking?")
2.Coda (Too repetitive and not a season finale)
3.(something from season 6 like u know anything from the 1st half, i cant name one, to be honest they are a bit of a blur to me but they definelty earn a spot in the top 5)
4.Lovelines(aside from there being no Pacey, I was bored)
5.Swan Song (Unrealistic and so obviously contrieved...yawn. Oh and they should have let jack and jen go to Costa Rica)

Cris

1. Lovelines: stupid, stupid and weak plotline. It wasn't DC...
2. Downtown Crossing: Joey singing to her mugger... please!
3. Show me Love: I hate it.
4. Castaways: too much for me to handle
5. Rock Bottom: I can't even remember the plot, but it was lame

Ms X

1.) Castaways...Like Cris, too much for me to handle and so unrealistic. Please they could have easily got out of the supermarket.

2). Love Lines....awful. So NOT DC

3) Show Me Love...Another contrived episode to show Dawson as a villian. It sucked.

4) Downtown Crossing....Ridicious to say the least. Hello Joey talking and singing to her mugger?? What the...?

5) The Anti Prom....Since when does Pacey remember everything, hated this. Again Dawson was made to look like a villian and I hated Joey's 'trophy' speech.

*Jenn*

alright...here are my top 5 worst Eppies:

1. Coda--Like Lou said, wayyy too repetitive from the s1 finale

2. Downtown Crossing--'nough said

3. Love Lines--Agree with what's been said, it's not DC at all, although JJ did a good job directing

4. The Kids are alright...the song remains the same--the titles say it all, it's always the same arguement

5. Swan Song--yeah

Songofjoy

My top 5
1. The season 5 halloween ep with Jack, Pacey & Joey. Can you say filler episode?
2. The episode where Joey Eddie and Audry take their cross country trip
3. The ep from season 6 where Joeys email is sent to the whole school
4. The Pacey in new Orleans ep
5. The season 6 christmas ep

FinallyPJ

Top 5
1. Coda - It seems like someone who never watched the show before wrote this episode.

2. Downtown Crossing - This episode was just plain sad.

3. Swan Song - Definately too much to handle.

4. Psychic Friends - This one just seemed too boring for me.

5. Lovelines - If I have to hear Eddie say "Why won't you get with me" one more time...argh.

loulalla

i just had to comment, finally, i cant stand how eddie kept saying why wont you get with me i mean jeez, thats the biggest turn off ever, it sounded so replsive and he kept syaing it over and over arghh yuk, i cant believe joey ended up sleeping with him, if that was me I would quiet honestly have dumped his ass.

*Jenn*

I don't know why he was pressuring her so much, just because she slept with him before doesn't mean she has to do it again and again...I mean he did just up and leave her! Why she would have gone back with him to begin with is just beyond me...not to get anything started or anything, but how could she have picked him over Pacey anyway!?

serialbathera

hmmm...
1. Downtown crossing- it is unrealistic
2. Castaways - seems like they ran out of plotlines so they stole a cliched one
3. Use you disillusion - because they changed Tobey and Jack's characters...and the whole thing just seemed like a weird episode to follow after Mitch's death
4. Show me love- it is just annoying
5. Sex and Violence - the Joey as pacey's assistant story line was just unbelievable, and cliche

loulalla

Thats why so many people hated eddie and joy it was totally unrealistic that joey would have chosen him over pacey and for that matter even dawson. They just wanted there to be no shipper favouring prior to the finale.

ring of fire

1- Show me love (season 3) - Horrible episode, stupid storyline and bad writing. This episode is like a torture. I can't watch it.

2- True love (season 3) - Cheap writing and one of the worst season finale I have seen. When I saw this episode I KNEW that Dawson's Creek was going downhill....

3- The anti-prom (season 3) - Another episode to reminds us all that Dawson was a bad guy and that Joey and Pacey should be together. Boring, boring, boring.

4- Coming home (season 4) - The show was really using the same storylines over and over.... By season 4 was tired of the Dawson/Joey/Pacey triangle.

5- Downtown crossing (season 5) - This episode was like WTF? What was the point of this episode??

~Unfaithful~

1) Castaways..........pure garbage. I'm supposed to believe that 2 people who barely talked to eachother all season would end up making out in a K-Mart?

2)Downtown Crossing......it was on when I was in labor, that was enough torture!

3)Coming Home.......the beginning of the end. Too much P/J fighting and then smoochies for me to handle.

4)The Song remains the same.......because the writers really had to do it, they really had to make Dawson out to be the bad guy yet again!

5)Merry Mayhem......enough with the cracked-out Audrey. I really liked her, but they ruined that character!

KatieNap

My top 5 worst episodes are

1. Promicide...too unbelievable that Pacey would treat Joey like that...No Way!

2. Coda...You will never get me to believe that she would Kiss Dawson again that quickly. She still had feelings for Pacey...

3. The Kids are Alright...She is practically swooning over Pacey in the beginning of the episode and then we're expected to believe that she winds up with Dawson
The worse love scene I have ever seen!!

4. Love Bites...I will never believe this one...she went through how many episodes feeling something...kissing him with passion...to say the next day...
I don't feel anything...they make her out to be so wishywashy...and how they expected us to believe she would pick Eddie over pacey..LOL..LOL...LOL...LOL

5. Lovelines... Just plain bad writing...no continuity at all...

loulalla

New one
Top 5 worst hairstyles
1. Dawsons greasy stringy gross hair start of season 4
2. Gail Season 1-waaaay to big!!!
3. Jens crop cut end of season 6--why oh why did she cut it it looked so good before
4. Eddie hair all the time- eddie annoys me so does his hair
5. Jens short hair in season 2- it was just kinda weird

*Jenn*

good one Lou! And less controversial

1. Dawson's hair in s4, nothing personal
2. Jen's short hair in s2
3. Pacey's s6 hair--Liked the facial hair, but I thought his hair kind of looked like Frankenstein--after Castaways, it got better (My fellow Pacey Lovers...PLEASE don't hate me!)
4. Joey's multi-colored hair in s6
5. Gails s2 hair--I agree with you, it was just too '80s