Forwood4Bamon

this.

Ms X

For me I disagree. In that scene, yes Dawson behaved badly but frankly both guys were not better then one another. Perhaps Pacey has more compassion then Dawson in a sense but neither guy is better then the other. Both have their faults and both have their great qualities.

Forwood4Bamon

true.

Ali

The best part of the ep was the That's your history? scene. Pacey speaks so much truth.

Idk if Dawson was ever more unlikable than he was in this ep.

Forwood4Bamon

word. he got on my nerves.

msstock87

I remember wanting to punch Dawson in this episode through my TV screen.

Forwood4Bamon

yea I wanted to punch him too.

JJH85

You nailed it. The spoiled little brat trait definitely came out in this episode with Dawson. I find that episode very hard to watch.

Ali

I love Jack for trying to be the voice of reason when Dawson asked him for the boat. Too bad it didn't work lol.

msstock87

I agree, this episode is so maddening to me because of how horrible Dawson acted.

Forwood4Bamon

word!

Alexa

Lets cool it on the Dawson bashing please?

I agree the guy was acting childish but he wasn't in a good mental place. He was still really hurting over what PJo did to him, so I can forgive his actions for a while.

I liked to see Andie supporting Dawson because they were both hurting.

I don’t blame Joey for not wanting to jump back into friendship with Dawson. After giving that ultimatum I imagine it would just feel weird.

Jen just needs to break up with Henry, she obviously doesn’t feel the same about him that he does to her.

I felt bad for Pacey this episode, dealing with Dawson's antics and then seeing Joey stick up for him. But, he had to know that getting involved with Djo's ex wouldnt be smart.

The P/D talk was awkward and frustrating to watch, i CANT STAND when they fight. The only feelings whose matter here are Joey's! So it doesnt matter what pacey OR dawsons thing, only Joey can decide what she wants. And right now she wants Pacey so they both need to accept it.

The pacey/andie scene at the end was so cute. I love that she was the one to pick the sign out of the water.

I liked the DJ scene at the end but you could tell it was very strained.

JJH85

No Dawson bashing, but it is fair to say he was not at his best in this episode.

Does anyone else think it's cute how Jack is so green when it comes to boats even though his dad owns a boat? We also saw that in S2 on the fishing trip.

I was totally over the whole Henry thing and was ready to move on from that.

I was glad Pacey had Will for a friend since he and Dawson were on the outs.

I liked how calm Pacey was when talking to |Joey about the race and also when he goes to talk to Dawson at Joey's request. It shows that he really does have Joey's best interests at heart which is just another reason I love Pacey so much.

flaminga

I didn't really like Pacey asking Joey if she could ever love him like a soulmate. It seemed out of character to me.

Butterfly85

I agree. I find this episode hard to watch too cause of what a douchebag Dawson is in it (especially being so passive aggressive and OVER DRAMATIC) how alone Pacey is, Andie being a bitter, hypocritical b, and the beginning of Joey basically being Dawson's slave I agree that one of the great things about the episode is Pacey showing once again he's the better man and shows class. Especially when Dawson had to be a stupid, violent maniac and almost crashed into Pacey's boat so he could win his overdramatic "My YKW is bigger than yours" broadway play he was doing in this episode Like I said, I bet Dawson would of had this reaction no matter when Pacey or Joey told him about thier relationship. I'm sure that's one of the reasons they were so scared and unsure what to do or tell him.