^ I just read that! Thanks for bringing it over, Jen
Hmm, not sure I like the sound of it. Sounds very cliche (musical romance etc). The main reason I enjoyed the movie is Ryan as Noah, who (as director Nick Cassavetes said,) was such a "strange" choice for a romantic lead that it made the character work, because he wasn't acting the part like an average romantic lead usually would. Noah had layers, because of the dramatic gravitas brought by Ryan who before that movie hadn't had experience in playing romantic parts.