Possibly
but I think the hateful reactions against TLJ have mostly been unjust by people who try to identify too much with Luke to the point where they think it's ridiculous that he would consider murdering Ben... This is Star Wars. Many characters have made these decisions and had these thoughts based on Light vs Dark impacts on the galaxy, and so for the haters to claim "Luke is OOC" it's just utter garbage and it's not a fair reason to hate on the movie
