Exactly!

I just find it impossible to explain away Brooke seasons 1-4, parts of 4 but especially seasons 1-3. How do you explain her behavior as anything but disgusting given what she did to Peyton and at times, even Lucas? She manipulated everything! She cried victim after torturing Peyton and even Lucas. She was just horrible. You cannot explain away her behavior! All the Brooke stans have on Peyton is the two kisses... BUT without admitting Brooke instigated the entire situation. Funny how that works. The entire story isn't told. But they cannot punch at Peyton's heart yet think Brooke was just fine and an ultimate victim in the early seasons. Right on.