Okay, this was originally a double post, so I'm just gonna edit it into a results post:
Results of Favorite Reaction Gifs Ranking
Since there was so much variety, I just went with the only gif that got multiple votes:
1. MY EMOTIONS!
This was the only gif to overlap on any of the lists! 
This means that it was the easiest results post ever!
Sarah and April both ranked it 4th on their lists.
Alexa's Gifs
Sarah's Gifs
April's Gifs
Paula's Gifs
Becks's Gifs
Paulina's Gifs