Double-posting just to share the results. These are our season 2 choices:

December 19th - 25th: 2.10 ”The Bracebridge Dinner"
December 26th - January 1st: 2.13 ”A-Tisket, A-Tasket"
January 2nd - 8th: 2.17 ”Dead Uncles and Vegetables"

(Feel free to start earlier if you like, though! Or keep sharing general season 1 and/or season 2 thoughts.)
I'll try to watch "The Bracebridge Dinner" on Saturday, December 19th at noon EST if anyone wants to watch at the same time.