I knew that pic was from his Fringe Days.
******************
So we found out today during Josh's Live Q&A on FB that Cole actually has 3 Tattoos, so I am now on a mission to find the 3rd Tattoo which brought me here. After looking at a couple of the pics, I noticed a slight difference in that larger 2nd Tattoo. Does anyone see any differences between the two pics? I have to admit, that first pic gives me butterflies.