ADD MEE TOO!!!
Ok, here's my theory on what happened to Baelfire, Ok, it's not my theory, I got it from another forum, but it makes sense I really want to share it with you guys!
Baelfire is Henry's father, and here's my evidence:
-Baelfire landed in our world before the curse took effect. This means that he was outside of the curse, like Emma.
-The Blue Fairy called the green vortex a "time hole." This might place the age and timeline discrepency back on track.
-Emma said that Henry's father was older than her. If Baelfire landed in our world right before the curse took effect, then he would definitely be older than her.
-Emma also said that Henry's father was a fireman. Maybe this a play on Baelfire's name. The names in Storybrooke always play on the identities of their fairytale counterparts.
-Mr. Gold: Because he spun gold back in fairytale land,
-Regina Mills: Because she is the daughter of the original millers daughter,
-Mary Margaret: This is the alias she gave Red in "Red Handed."
So, names and certain personal attributes play a big role in this show.
-It would also explain why Emma has platinum blonde hair while Henry's hair is almost black.