Will add this to OP:

We currently have 26 (?) songs in the Finn/Rachel fanmix, and would like to cut it down to around 15-20 songs, so here's what we'll do:

1) Take a look at the song and lyrics list
2) PM me (Rinslet) the 5 songs you feel fits Finn/Rachel the LEAST.

I will remove the Top 6 or something (depending on ties) songs from the fanmix so we don't have a HUGE list.