 | | 12-03-2008, 08:53 AM |
|
#44 |
| Addicted Fan
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 4,338
| i'm sorry if it's a bit OT 
Quote: | She found her soulmate - yeah, but what if the love dies? What if Liz gets tired of fighting? Like I said she is no super girl to me, and I don't believe she can do it forever. People get tired, and in some point she might too. | this is not what the show told  and neither the original books
the one you're taking about is a Liz that doesn't exist because Liz proved that she couldn't get tired (even when she was she couldn't stop and in the end she had no regrets). it's the whole point of the story. change it and it isn't the same story anymore, it's another Liz. not the one Melinda and Katims created. i find it inevitable. it's not about being super girl. it's about the foundation of her character and the original story. for Katims and Melinda the character that *they* made is in love and will always love Max (and viceversa) otherwise they would have written the story into another way, they would have written Liz into another way.
after all the things she lived the future can't bring for her (them) things worse than all the other things she already survived. everything will be a joke compared to what she already faced and won against.
and no, her love can't die for me (this is what the show told. i don't remember a different ending). otherwise it means that i didn't understand the core point of roswell and their relationship and why it was so different compared to other shows/stories (a relationship that obviously isn't "realistic" for many even if i personally know some people who loved the same person for their whole life. maybe because the big example i got are my parents and it's not that their life was always nice and easy, the contrary.)
I'm a dreamer because their relationship is that different and they proved it to me.
i understand your point because you obviously love UC and crossover Liz
but i don't have the same ability especially with stories that had its beginning and definitive closure.
when it's about alternative universe i find crossovers more tolerable and believable but with regular fanfictions no no
see i don't have a problem with UC shippers in general
i appreciate people that can love the canon couples and at the same time they like the originality of uc couples too but they never confuse it with canon and they know that in the canon it isn't possible to get certain couples.
for example i've read the opinion of a Max/Maria fan who admits that yes she loves the couple into fanfictions but she also knows that in the original story it was pretty impossible.
Quote:
Edit. But the fact that Liz is in so many crossover fics and so used character, just proves how amazing she is.  | i don't know if i can honestly reply to this because my opinion could hurt someone.
i'm not talking about you but i honestly don't think that *every* uc_liz shipper is really a *Liz* fan.
Last edited by *Coccy* : 12-03-2008 at 09:05 AM.
|
| Reply With Quote |