I liked the eppy and didn't think it was bad,but the the lack of MD was a letdown for me and for many people I know
I really liked Derek on it,he wasn't being pushy to Meredith and just agreed to take things slow and showed her support when Richard was yelling at her,its a good start to see Derek coming through for her .
As for Rose,I'm gonna say Derek deserves the treatment she give him and a part of me was glad not to see get off the hook so easily,but there was no need to make remarks in the OR when a surgeon is trying to save someone life here that was childish,she should have just ignored and been professional and Derek got redeemed a bit in my opinion after he had the look: what what hell was I thinking dating her LOL.That pretty much wrapped up the whole Dose fiasco.