 | | 03-16-2008, 09:34 AM |
|
#66 |
| Master Fan
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 10,651
| Woah! Calm down.....
And you claim to not get worked up over fictional characters. Everyone that posts on this board does. If we didn't care about them then why would we bother disscussing them online?
2ndly, This has nothing to do with Juliet at all. I just came in here because sometimes I read/post about EM.
I wasn't even talking about Kate not liking Juliet. I was just saying that its understandable from Kate and Sun's point of view why they would think its best to go to Locke's group. Juliet and us viewers know more than Kate and Sun do on the topic of pregnant women on the island. My point being that due to circumstance, they have conflicting views with Juliet about what they think is right thing to do.
And I'm not saying Juliet was wrong. She did the right thing. I just don't feel that Kate and Sun deserve criticism for what they thought. It's not like they have been studying as fertility docters on the island. I think a major theme of the show is how good people get pitted against eachother and become foes.
Quote: |
And thirdly, Kate spent two days in Otherville. She knows the kind of gig Locke is running there. He frakking banished her and doesn't want to get off the island. Knowing Sun's condition, is encouraging her to go there really the best advice? Whether she understands Sun's reasoning or doubts Juliet to some degree, there's also the 50% chance she's telling the truth. She's willing to take that risk with Sun's life and her unborn child? It wasn't very logical, IMO.
| Yes, but you have to remember that Kate has a different perspective than us viewers she knows very little compared to what we know. So I think from Kate's point of view, she doesn't see a statistical chance of whether or not Juliet is telling the truth. But your points about Locke not being the most saintly guy on the island are very valid. If that is the angle you were coming at, then I understand your criticism. But I still disagree. If you want to know why I do, I'll tell in the Kate thread 
Last edited by Jenna16 : 03-16-2008 at 10:18 AM.
|
| |