Fan Forum - View Single Post - 5.09 'For Tonight You're Only Here To Know' Episode Discussion.

samanta · 02-28-2008, 12:20 PM

I think this episode has probably been the one that I don´t really feel anything about

I found it weird that there were so many scenes with the girls and basically 1 to 2 scenes with Lucas and Nathan.

I didn´t like the way the girls were being portrayed while being in the library.Peytons and Lindsays catfight is definitely getting old - more so Peytons than Lindsays actually bc in my opinion Lindsay is just sticking up for herself.Not that it justifies any of their behaviour or what they say to each other but it does always feel like Peyton is the one that always starts it.
The dad comment was of course a bit too much - but the comment was said in anger so I don´t really think that Peyton should be judged all that hard - obviously if she knew what happened to Lindsays dad she wouldn´t have said it - so her emotions got the better of her.Just like it happened with Brooke and she made those comments about Peytons moms.The comments are all made during a fury moment where you don´t think rationally but just blurt whatever is on your mind in order to hurt that person. With that being said I was glad to see how Peyton approached Lindsay and apologized for what she said.That was definitely needed and I was glad to see Peyton actually acting like a grown up for a change.
Lindsay was great and she made me tear up when she said that she was actually rooting for LP but that her and Lucas now wrote their own chapter and she wouldn´t apologize for that.That was definitely one of Michaela´s best scenes.

As for Brooke - I loved the few scenes she had but honestly I didn´t really see what the purpose of her even was in this episode.The same goes with Haley.It´s as if they were only there to stop Peyton/Lindsay from ripping each others head off which I find ridiculous.

The pro Victoria speech Brooke gave was heartwrenching though.No matter what a terrible mother Victoria might be, she is Brooke´s mother and even though Victoria doesn´t love her daughter unconditionally, Brooke definitely showed that she loved her mother that way.

Her reaction when she had to call Owen and then her battery died was so funny and cute.Sophia is the best at expressions like that

Tim,I am glad he is back.He is just the same he always was

It was sad though when he told them noone keeps in touch anymore.Not even him and Nathan who used to be so close

Jaime - absolute

That kid is so precious and just lights up the screen.

BP - I just love them.This is the most powerfull their relationship has ever been.They know each other so well and have such an amazing chemistry.The way Peyton came up to her with the booze and then put her arms around her was just