 | | 04-20-2007, 10:27 AM |
|
#231 |
| New Fan
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 73
| Quote: | The thing about ASP vs DSR, is that even when I didn't like one of Amy's storylines, I never questioned if she cared about the characters. I do question that with DSR. He's not invested the way ASP was, the way we are. It's a job to him. And it's a job he hasn't done very well.
Even when I didn't like one of ASP's plots, I at least understood the characters' motivations. I don't get that with DSR. It goes beyond bad storytelling with him. I don't always feel like he has an understanding of who these characters are.
I miss the Palladinos. |
Yes. The Palladinos cared about the characters they created; Rosenthal does not. But, as show runner Rosenthal and his writers should at least go back to the old episodes and even old notes, if there are any, so they will stay loyal to the Palladinos' vision.
Right now, from all the spoilers around, Rory and Logan are both out of character. Knowing how Logan can read Rory, why in the world would he propose so publicly? And, Rory, knowing how Logan would do anything for her, why would she push him away?
It is just so depressing that the storyteller who is supposed to be able to continue the work of the Palladinos is turning everything into chaos. Just awful. |
| |