Season 1
I just have never seen better writing, acting, or chemistry on a tv show.
Season 3
Mostly because of the Ephram/Amy romantic relationship finally being explored.
Season 4
I loved how Ephram and Amy slowly built up the trust and friendship again while realizing they were never going to be just friends (them sleeping together and Amy admitting he is her person). And then of course it all leading to the finale where Amy realized she wanted him again for good, that was incredibly wonderful. The best series finale ever.
Season 2
I loved Amy through all of it but Im with you
Michelle the Ephram/Madison obsession/storyline makes me cringe and I hated Madison so it definitely ruined alot of season 2 for me. Its weird because I didnt mind Amy's attitude with Tommy (and to some extent Colin in season 1) because I know theyd never last, but I found EM sick and unhealthy considering the age difference, his obsession with her, and her knowing she couldnt get past the age difference and leading him on.
